lichen moths: bright, beautiful, bizarre

Painted lichen mothIT WAS 90-SOMETHING DEGREES OUT, but the lichen patterning on one patio stone looked like snowflakes, and I took a photo. That morning, I had shot another picture, of an insect I didn’t know. When it got so hot out later, I went inside to key it out and found that nature had served up another miracle: I’d met my first lichen moth within hours of taking that “snowflake” lichen image. I knew right away who to ask about the moth, at least: Seabrooke Leckie, co-author of the “Peterson Guide to Moths of Northeastern North America.” Learn some amazing facts about these specialized moths–why they paint themselves in flame colors, for instance, and how they have become expert “poop flingers” (I kid you not!)–and maybe win a copy of a favorite guidebook I turn to all the time in summer.

My new acquaintance (top photo) was Hypoprepia fucosa, the painted lichen moth, one of a group of mostly bright-colored insects listed in the guide as lichen moths.

First I refreshed my memory a bit on lichen, of which there are three kinds: those that grow on trees or shrubs (epiphytic types); others that grow on the ground (terrestrial); and ones like those on my terrace—rock-dwelling, or saxicolous lichens. The painted lichen moth doesn’t have a relationship with that lichen on my patio stones, but rather with the epiphytic types, I quickly learned, but I wanted to know more, and dashed off a series of questions to Seabrooke (who with the Northeast moth guide collaborator David Beadle is currently working on a Southeast volume):

Q. What is this group of moths’ relationship to lichens, anyhow?

A: One of the fascinating things about moths as a group is that if it in any way resembles a plant, there’s a moth that eats it. There are many species of moths that eat the leaves and other parts of vascular plants, of course, including aquatic plants, but there are also some that feed on detritus on the forest floor (appropriately called “litter moths”), some that feed on fungi, some that feed on moss, and of course some that feed on lichen.

Most of the time, when a moth species has a plant included in its common name, it’s because its caterpillars feed primarily or sometimes exclusively on that plant. In the case of lichen moths, their caterpillars feed on lichen and sometimes blue-green algae. Certain members of the group can also be cannibalistic on smaller individuals of their own species.

Q. Any idea why they are so colorful? (Doesn’t seem like they’re trying to hide from predators with those outfits on, but I know it must aid survival somehow and isn’t just a fashion statement.)

A: You’ll notice that the lichen moths, those that are colored, are mostly yellow/orange/red and black. Typically in the insect kingdom this combination of flame-family colors with black is an indication of distastefulness–a visual warning to potential predators not to waste their time.

Such coloration is termed “aposematic.” Usually, this unpalatability is because the insect contains chemicals that it ingested and metabolized as a larva and retained through metamorphosis into an adult.

Perhaps the best-known example of this is the monarch butterfly, which gets alkaloids from milkweed. Some species “piggy-back” on predator recognition of these distasteful species through mimicry–for instance, the viceroy butterfly looks similar enough to the monarch to gain that protection.

It’s unclear whether the lichen moths are the former or the latter, although at least one species–the black-and-yellow lichen moth (Lycomorpha pholus)–is a mimic of distasteful net-winged beetles, and members of the very closely related and similarly aposematic tiger moth group are unpalatable.

Q. OK, I have to ask: I have read about projectile pooping (my unscientific term!) by caterpillars. What’s up with that?

A: If you hold a caterpillar in your hand for long, there’s a good chance it will poop on you. But the poop isn’t messy–it’s in compact, dark-green pellets.

Some species of lichen moth, including our relatively common scarlet-winged and painted lichen moths (Hypoprepia miniata and H. fucosa, respectively), are expert poop-flingers as caterpillars.

They have a specialized “comb” that folds under their body at their rear end; when they need to fling a pellet, they force haemolymph (insect blood) into the last body segment which causes the spring-loaded comb to pop out and eject the pellet–it can be tossed as far as 30 body lengths away. This behavior is believed to be intended to foil parasitic and predatory wasps and flies that hone in on prey using the volatiles (evaporating chemicals) in the pellets.

Q. Remind me about why some caterpillars are so hairy—what purpose(s) do the hairs, which can be pretty dense, play?

A: Lichen moths, along with the closely-related tiger moths, and the not-so-closely-related tussock moths, have hairy caterpillars (usually, though not always, densely so). These hairs are typically urticating–that is, they irritate soft membranes (like mouth linings) or sensitive skin. It’s another defense against predation.

When they’re building their cocoons to pupate, the caterpillars will incorporate these hairs into the cocoon’s structure, binding them together with silk. A few species of lichen moths build very elaborate structures that look less like a cocoon and more like a cage. (Some great examples here.)

They carefully bind the hairs together in straight lines, forming a loose grid that arches above the pupa; the pupa hangs suspended from silken threads in the middle, equidistant from the sides, and far enough in that parasitoids can’t reach it through the cocoon to lay eggs. The hairs at the top and bottom ends point outward and aren’t bound together, which acts as a sort of reverse fish trap–when the adult moth emerges, it can easily push out of the structure, but nothing can get in.

how to win the field guide to moths

Peterson Field Guide to Moths of Northeastern North AmericaI’VE BOUGHT AN EXTRA COPY of the Peterson’s Northeast moth guide to share with a lucky reader. All you have to do to win is answer the question:

Where are you in your relationship to moths? I know, I am being a little flip–but here’s what I mean: Is “moth” still synonymous with “nondescript tan pest in the pantry or sweater drawer, and flying around the porch light at night,” or have you noticed anybody more distinguished yet?

Since I got the moth guide when it came out last year, it has changed the way I define the word “moth” completely.

Don’t have a moth story, but want to win the book? Just say “count me in” or something like that, and I will. I’ll draw the winner at random after entries close at midnight Sunday, August 18. Good luck to all.

  1. Debby says:

    I love seeing the Rosy Maple moth, it is so colorful with the bright pink and yellow! But the elegant Luna is my favorite, so beautifully dressed up in a pale green ballgown.

  2. Jan C. says:

    love them, but only recognize a few. I try to get people to NOT squish the tomato hornworm, just move it off of your good tomato onto a cherry tomato plant. Sometimes Mother Nature has already put a biological control on it in the form of a little wasp, and if it survives, the beautiful moth is an important pollinator!

  3. Anne Eby says:

    Last spring I uncovered a very large pupa while digging my flower beds. I put it in a gallon jar and we watched it closely. After a long while, It hatched into a huge yellow and brown moth. After searching, I found it was an Imperial moth. It was an enjoyable experience. I would enjoy having the guide and sharing it with my grandchildren.

  4. Kim Fellows says:

    Thank you for counting me in on your book giveaway … saw two beautiful moths up in Georgian Bay Islands National Park this summer, so this book would help identify them.

  5. Lyne says:

    For the past 10 years, I have been creating a wildlife habitat. My link to moths and all creatures is a natural curiosity. One thing for sure, I have noticed many moths that “wake-up” during my daytime chores. Knowing more about their habits is a plus. Love your website!

  6. Eileen says:

    I enjoy reading your newsletter.
    It is interesting to learn about all the different species.
    Count me in. I welcome the opportunity to learn more.

  7. Jackie P. says:

    I’ve had the pleasure of seeing some beautiful and strange moths over the years. I have seen the beautiful lunar moth many times. This summer I spotted an unfamiliar, rather large moth in my dry watering can. Not sure if it was still living, I turned it out into the grass. It was about 2-1/2″ from tip to tip with a much wider wingspan. It was stll alive – dark gray with white and black bands. It triangular shape reminded me of a stealth fighter jet — without the fear of attack! Quite facsinating — have not identified it yet, but the moth field guide looks like a must-have since we have so many interesting moths in southern NH. Thanks for opening up the decussion.

  8. Brenda says:

    I’ve found some of the most beautiful “butterflies” are actually moths (like a luna moth!). I’m sure I could get a lot of use out of that book!

  9. Nadine says:

    Oh I love moths! So much so in fact, that I do not eradicate tomato hornworms because I’ve read they become gorgeous moths…I’m waiting to see!
    Happy Day to all!

  10. Jim says:

    I used to “collect” luna moths when I was a kid – every summer I’d find at least a few clinging to the outside screen door or one of the windows – amazing creatures (I just kept them in a jar for a little while…never killed them..except that one for my 7th grade insect project). Sadly, I don’t think I’ve seen even a single one in the past 25 years…I wonder where they’ve all gone. Unfortunately, I’m now inundated with winter moths every year – their caterpillars are wreaking havoc on my apple, maple, and oak trees! I much prefer the luna variety :)

  11. Cindi says:

    I have been getting more interested in moths and butterflies. Mostly due to gardening issues but they are just as fascinating to the little grandsons!

  12. Catherine Roberts says:

    When I was a child I collected butterflies and moths the cruel way,
    death by lighter fluid in a jar, then stuck with a pin. Now I feel badly when I find a tattered roadkill. I only collect the already dead.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.