trouble in paradise: galls, beetles & more woes
I NTO EVERY GARDEN SOME PESTS MUST FALL. And creep, and crawl, and hatch, and wriggle, and pupate, and fly and tunnel, and just plain materialize and cause havoc. Paradise (or so the tour guests called it recently) has its share of troubles this year, more than I’ve ever seen, actually. Am I paying stricter attention, or are they out to get me in a bigger way than in years past? Hello lily beetles, viburnum leaf beetles, tent caterpillars, various fruit-tree borers, and my old friend cedar-apple rust (above). How are we going to learn to get along? Or are we?
CEDAR APPLE RUST is having a banner year here. So what do you do when you live with warring roommates? In the case of the back-and-forth rounds of battle between the towering Eastern red cedar (Juniperus virginiana) in my front yard and all apples and apple relatives around the place, nothing.
Well, I do watch in fascination, especially at the stage of cedar apple rust above (a few weeks ago), when orange, almost gelatinous “telial horns” are developing where the cedar galls were last fall and winter. I don’t intervene, despite the havoc this fungus causes, particularly foliar damage and defoliation of apple relatives (the reason my shadbush, or Amelanchier, and my oldest of apples lose their leaves so early each year; the reason I don’t even try to grow hawthorns).
Quince, crabapple and pear are some of the other plants similarly affected. Learn more about the fungus these host species pass back and forth like a hot potato (the entire cycle is diagrammed here, in a pdf).
VIBURNUM LEAF BEETLE: Someone on the blog recently said, “I can’t grow Viburnum because of the leaf beetle,” and I replied, “I’ve never had it here.” Famous last words.
My garden relies heavily on Viburnum, as do my beloved avian companions, and I bet there are more than 30 shrubs of numerous species and varieties in the garden. I have lost track.
One day in 2009, from a distance I noticed a catbird was intent on what looked like a dead shrub in the distance, but up close turned out to be a defoliated (but alive) Viburnum opulus, the cranberrybush viburnum. The catbird was having a wild time eating a glut of larvae (above) of the viburnum leaf beetle, who had just finished eating the foliage of the shrub. The food chain at work…until I interrupted it and squashed about 500 of them and cut off the worst branches, bagging them tightly for the trash.
I should have done this between October and April, before the eggs hatched into larvae; now I know.
Around the place I went, checking every Viburnum, expecting the worst. But only a couple of cranberrybush types that, like the defoliated one, were growing in pretty substantial shade, had any leaf damage, and slight at that. But why? Apparently there is natural resistance in many species, and you can get the list here if you wish to grow Viburnum but not ones that the beetle and its larvae adore. Onward to…
LILY BEETLES: I was likewise cheeky about lily beetles: I don’t have them, I told a reader, who wanted help tackling this voracious leaf-eating pest (above, the leaves before the onslaught). Well, now I do have them, and in fact have drowned many red (adult) beetles in recent years along with many more larvae who were eating my Martagon lilies.
Besides hand-picking, tactics for control friends have tried include Neem oil spray. All about lily leaf beetles and what progress is being made against this pest by researchers is explained by University of Rhode Island’s Lisa Tewksburg in detail at this link.
EASTERN TENT CATERPILLARS: I made the rounds in April with my bamboo cane, disrupting any weblike tents (above) I found and squashing anybody inside. As I’ve explained before, I do that to try to reduce the concentration of caterpillars hanging around in my favorite trees. I guess I missed a few; I’m seeing full-grown caterpillars more than I’d like to. Squish!
BARK BORERS IN FRUIT TREES: In 2008 I lost one of 10 crabapples to bark borers, and another suffered mightily (jury still out; it’s trying to be vigorous). A third tree (actually newly planted in spring 2008) succumbed in 2009. Here’s what I know about these tiny but disgusting creatures who can quietly fell a tree (including to get out your pyrethrin-based concoctions and a piece of wire to insert into their tunnels if you want to kill them).
As I post this, aphids are making a pass at my honeysuckles, and I know that Japanese beetles will show up by July 4th. Tomato hornworms and all the other annual tomato troubles show up in varying degrees each summer, too, and on and on. Exhausting business this gardening, no?
So who’s been causing trouble in your corner of paradise?

The eastern tent caterpillar is a native insect and a favored food of the cuckoo. So don’t kill all of the caterpillars or you won’t have any cuckoos–and I know you love birds.
My Juneberry always drops its leaves early and I never could figure out why. I am going to have to look into cedar-apple rust. I haven’t planted cedars but quite possibly there are some around.
Help! Chipmunks are invading my kitchen garden…”conversation tomatoes” now, parsley and other edibiles will be next. The entrance to their tunnel is nearby. What can I do?
Jane
First, I love your garden and have been lurking for sometime.I am a southern girl living in Wisconsin;long, cold winters kill me. Yours and other garden blogs get me through the rough times. Your garden is fabulous. Anyway, I noticed last week little holes in branches on a catalpa tree. The tree was planted 2 1/2 yrs ago. I saw pics of your borer damage and immediately ran out to snip off a now dead branch. I split it open and found what look like ants with wings, black with yellow stripes. The center of the branch is totally eaten, thus the dead branch. I will have my husband spraying my tree as soon as he gets home from work. Do you have any other suggestions.
Hey Margaret — Just received your e-mailed update and you’re using my pitcher! The turquoise one with the peonies — I use mine for peonies too. Very fun to see.
Wow, never realized cedar apple rust could resemble slices of red pepper. Yuck and fascinating at the same time. Good luck with the squishing.
I’ve had more pests this year as well…and I had the same problem with my viburnum (and the same solution – my fingers were stained with bug juice). Never before have I had a problem with voles or moles (I don’t know which) but this year they were in all my beds to disastrous effect with several perennials. I spent a fortune on castor oil pellets and their activity seems to have subsided. I used to think deer were the worst!
Loved seeing your beautiful garden on the Sunday “Open Day”. I hadn’t paid much attention to the pale pumpkin colored heuchera until I saw how you planted it next to chartreuse foliage plants – fabulous! I am in Green River, at the northern edge of Hillsdale, just north of you, and my viburnums have been badly hit with little black bugs which now seem to have left, leaving behind curled, crumpled leaves. Was that an early stage of the beetle you discussed?
Hi Margaret. I loved the open day in “Paradise.” I especially enjoyed seeing the containers you assembled at the workshop in their native habitat. ;-)
I’ve recently discovered that an old-style heuchera of mine, the kind that blooms late, is absolutely infested with spider mites. I thought it looked really puny this year. I only saw the webs when I was watering one recent afternoon. So, I sprayed with a horticultural oil and water mix, carefully spraying the underside of each tiny leaf. Then I took a closer look at the heucheras caramel I recently planted. Lo and behold, there was a spider mite web developing there as well! So, I sprayed them with horticultural oil as well.
I know how much you like the heuchera caramel, so I wanted to give you a warning. Also, I wanted to ask whether you can recommend any cure for spider mites. They seem really devilish and hard to get rid of. Thanks!
I am in a quandry over my potatoes I bought at Ronnigers per your suggestion..Last year was my first year, and I decided to plant them in tires- all was working great till around July and then all of a sudden all the leaves disappeared.It must have been a bug- I got nothing in return. This year I bought these felt buckets from Gardeners Supply for the taters and covered them with straw- I got the spuds at Ronnigers like you suggested. I planted them about the first week of May but I have seen no growth. What am I doing wrong?? I live in the metro NY area- Northern Westchester- near Martha..Any suggestions?? Thanks
I lived all winter with an infestation of lady bugs, thinking “this is a good sign, they’ll move out of the house when it gets warm and protect my garden!” Yeah, right. Apparently they moved out and *fled* because my beans are now infested with aphids. And anyone that knows me knows I don’t take lightly to vertebrates or invertebrates messing with my beans. So I caved and bought some insecticidal soap. I know it makes me a bad person, but man, I just can’t fathom the thought of a summer without shell beans.
We’ve been inundated with pests here also. It seems as though this year is particularly bad. For us here, it was so cool and damp for so long, that I think many of them got a head start! I’ve had a devil of a time starting things from seed, as the pill bugs are munching things as soon as they germinate! + leaf rollers decimating the new growth on the fruit trees! leaf miner, tent caterpillars. I’m just waiting with bated breath to see what goes after the squash and tomatoes! It feels a bit like a battleground!
Unfortunately my prized Japanese black pine succumbed this year to a pine borer infestation. This was my favorite tree in the yard, but I’m not going to try another; seems that borers really like black pines.
Welcome, Mary W. Wow, don’t send those here…I have a lot of twig dogwoods. Yikes. But I like your attitude…roll w/the punches! See you soon.
Welcome, Femme1. Yes, that must be it: I made it irresistible for them. :) I will work on that and wreck the place; that’s the ticket! See you soon I hope, too.
Margaret, it’s my first time posting here, but I discovered your blog a while back and read everyday. I’m in southern Indiana (also zone 5) but we have hotter summers.
I’m wondering if bug problems become worse as gardens fill in and become more lush, with plants touching other plants? Could it be that your garden is just so lush and alluring that all the bugs are telling their little bug friends to come and vacation at your place?
Dogwood sawfly larvae. We have some red twig dogwood bushes and the sawfly larvae can destroy a bush in a day. I was upset the first year, but then realized I don’t really like the bushes (weedy, invasive and not as decorative as I’d hoped), so now I don’t care and the bushes don’t seem to either.
Welcome, Sierra. Sounds like we are in the same boat, but gaining on it, hopefully. See you soon again, I hope (preferably when we can both report success). :)
I’ve been vainly attempting to nurse the two existing apple trees back to the point where they’ll bloom. They get the powderey mildew that then progresses to the leaves looking like they’ve been scorched and I’ve resisted having them sprayed. I know, next year. I am braced for the japanese beetles but in the meantime I keep undoing the “nests” that my mysterious critter keeps burrowing into the beds. The skunks and squirrels continue uprooting plants in their quest to dig up tasty treats and a rabbit took some chunks out of the trunk of my ironwood. Nature, why must you insist on having it your way?
At least the slugs drown their sorrows in the saucers of cheap beer that I offer them.
Last night I discovered some kind of pest/disease on my baby river birch leaves. I’m going to bag one and take it to the garden center to find out what it is. I have big plans for this tree so I hope it’s not deadly!
Do possums count? I’ve tried netting the brassicas, and they eat through it. I’ve set up an electric fence, and they jump over it. I’ve even been “marking my territory” in strategic locations, but they simply ignore it. Beetroot, chard, strawberries, rhubarb leaves all get attacked, and short of putting out a plate of food, I’m just about ready to go to war against the little blighters!
You think you are the only one with those problems. Ha, Think again. Universal problems, “Bugs” Arn’t they great they have everybody chasing around trying to get rid of them.
Smart or not so smart creatures they have a ball aggravating gardeners every year.
Have a great evening,
John
This year I just begun gardening in my mom’s garden. Planted a couple new lilies. This is the first year for us that the little troublemaking scarlet lily beetles have gone at our lilies. And how they went at them! They spared the two I planted this season, but the foliage on many are sadly ruined. I recently bought insecticidal soap, and soaked them all down, paired with hand-picking. Hoping I ended the misery for my lilies. As for other pests… we shall see!
I keep telling myself ‘birds eat bugs, birds eat bugs’ as I’m squishing aphids and beetles by hand. And the birds this year have been many and frequent! I did use neem oil early in the season after our discussion last year…and I thought, okay I’ll do this every few days…FOR THE REST OF THE SEASON. But no lily beatles in weeks?! Broken cycle? Not celebrating yet, but the lily foliage isn’t lacelike this year!
My walks through the woods including carrying a big strong stick to wreak havoc on every tent caterpillar nest I could reach…horrible defoliating things.
I’m not even going to whisper the words ‘leaf beetle’ in hopes that that particular plague passes me and my viburnums by.
Man, it’s like you’re writing about my garden! I’m trying to fight off the aphids every day now as they just get started on my honeysuckle. They were so bad on the plum tree of my diamond-shaped espalier that it didn’t leaf this year. And, the dwarf apple next to it on the espalier was overtaken by galls. I took them both out and replaced them with pear trees. Now I have a half an espalier. It’ll be years before it’s back to where it was. I almost cried. But my wife yelled at me, “There’s no crying in gardening!”
Very sorry to hear you’re being bugged. This spring seems to have provided the perfect conditions for a bug population explosion up here, too.
I remember when you said you weren’t bothered by lily beetles. The Chinese would never crow of their good fortune for fear the gods would hear them and spitefully take away their bounty. Could be the gods were listening in or maybe it’s just the weirdo weather we have had for the past year. I vote for the latter but just to cover your bases maybe you should hang a few more Tibetan prayer flags. Couldn’t hoyt;)