what are your top tomatoes?
NO, DON’T START TOMATO SEEDS YET, unless you are in some place far warmer than the snow cave I am lately residing in. But it’s prime time to shop for them—if you’re prepared to be overwhelmed at the choices. Some top tomatoes I have my eye on for 2014’s garden—and I hope you’ll tell me yours.
black is the new red
The “black” tomatoes (more brownish-purple than anything near black) often have a flavor that’s described as smoky, or earthy. You may have grown ‘Black Krim’ and ‘Cherokee Purple’—two very good ones—and now I’m eyeing ‘Carbon,’ which people are talking about. Same with ‘Paul Robeson,’ a tomato with a great taste (and a great story).
Want a black cherry tomato to mix things up in the salad bowl (that link will take you to one, as will this one)? Thinking larger, and darker: At the extreme of dark tomato color there’s open-pollinated ‘Indigo Rose,’ an Oregon State University development (photo above from High Mowing Seeds). It’s the first tomato with a truly black outside, and looks just like a plum.
for reliable sauce
Is there sauce in your future? I was for decades a diehard ‘Roma’ person, but the last several years I instead make sure that lovely ‘Juliet,’ a sturdy hybrid with big clusters of a dozen or more 2-inch fruit, is here to guarantee a crop. The open-pollinated ‘Amish Paste’ (like ‘Juliet,’ whose photo is below, it’s juicy and tasty for use in salads, too) and ‘Gilbertie’ paste are my other top contenders.
toughest tomatoes
Did you have tomato troubles last year—spotted leaves, defoliating plants and such? What about trying the first “triple-resistant” tomato, resistant to early blight, septoria and late blight, from the Cornell-North Carolina State breeding program? Well-named ‘Iron Lady’ is a determinate, mid-sized red slicer. (Again: Among sauce-making types, ‘Juliet’ is one tough girl, too, in my conditions.) If late blight, specifically, was your issue, this story from the archive offers additional advice (or read all about other tomato troubles at this link).
tasty golden cherries
I can’t imagine the summer garden without the tropical-fruity flavored ‘Sun Gold’ (a hybrid), but admittedly its can have the troublesome tendency to crack. The newer ‘Esterina’ is crack-resistant, and very sweet and complex-flavored (though admittedly without that tropical tang). And what about ‘Galina’? I’ve heard tell she is a distinctive little golden thing, too.
not your average ‘sweet million’
Want to try something different in red cherry tomatoes–not the same ubiquitous hybrids from the garden centers? Two I have enjoyed many times over the years: ‘Matt’s Wild Cherry’ (a profusion of small fruit, originally introduced by Johnny’s) and the larger, extra-delicious ‘Chadwick’s Cherry’ (named for the bio-intensive garden guru Alan Chadwick). Turtle Tree Seeds has both.
extra-early dwarfs, grown in pots
One for a pot, perhaps? My friend Gayla Trail of You Grow Girl dot com loves the little guys—dwarf tomatoes, which fruit faster than larger plants. To further speed them along, she starts charmers with names like ‘Whippersnapper’ extra-early (in March, versus April for her other tomatoes); here’s the lowdown on the tastiest of the lot, for pots.
but which brandywine?
I often say, “A Brandywine isn’t a Brandywine isn’t a Brandywine,” meaning with heirloom and other open-pollinated varieties, what you get depends how carefully the seed farmer selected to keep their strain true to type. And then there are also the variations by color: a pink and a red, and even a yellow (photo above)—shall we try all three?
biggest of the biggies
I can’t stop thinking of the whopper of a tomato I met at an event at Hudson Valley Seed Library last year, a tomato called ‘Upstate Oxheart’ (above). Insane. and so tasty, too. Oh, how can I make room for all of these varieties?
I know—I’ve left out entire categories (such as striped tomatoes, or extra-early slicers, or…). But that’s where you hopefully come in. Any must-have tomatoes to suggest?




I would grow Indigo Rose just for its beauty but there are SO many new varieties in the Indigo series and I grew a couple last year and they were far superior to Rose in taste. Check out how many they have this season at Log House. WOWSA:
https://loghouseplants.com/plants/page/1/?s=INDIGO%E2%84%A2+&post_type=product
I love this topic! I always have to try something new but I always come back to: Paul Robeson, Sun Gold, Green Zebra, Pineapple, and Stupice.
Wow! Lots of great ideas. I am a bit of a tomato nut and grow too many, but what the heck! Last year I grew Juliette(always a great performer and delicious); a lovely cherry called Chocolate Cherry, which was deep and rich and very prolific; Indigo Rose– mine taste fine, and add great color to my salsa fresca; Black Krim and Black Sea, which were delicious, but I think I grew them too close and they cross-pollinated so I couldn’t tell one from the other; a pineapple that I got one small fruit off of; a roma-type called Fresh Salsa that is firm and dry, so it makes great salsa; and I know we’re supposed to be supporting heirlooms, but the best performer I ever have is the “Parks Whopper Hybrid”. It grows perfectly year after year for me, even when I don’t get it in until the end of May! There were a couple of yellow and gold–which I loved the lemony tast of, but which didn’t take off very well, so I intend to spread out and give everyone a bit more room this year.
(Yes, I know! Help me! I am being overtaken by tomatoes! LOL)
And now I have even more ideas from you folks. Thanks guys! *grin*
Some great idea
I like Black Krim Brandywine and CherokeePurple. I plant celebrity for canning.
I feel all fired up now … and ashamed of myself for buying the same boring varieties I buy every year! I love the thought of the black ones with their smoky flavour. I wish you could buy packets of seed which just have 2 or 3 of lots of different varieties in, so we could experiment a lot more.
That’s my problem too: my small veggie beds can only support a few different varieties, so a packet of even 25 seeds lasts for years. I usually swap seeds with other gardeners I know — we each buy a couple varieties and then share. :)
I love sweet 100’s cherry tomatoes but they crack easily with me, and want to check out others. So I’ve purchased tomato riesentraube seed, a German heirloom, from Baker Creek Heirloom and sweetie cherry tomato seed from High Mowing. I love the smokey flavor of Cherokee Purple.
Hoo-ray! For JULIET! My all-time favorite. It does everything I want in a tomato.
I live about 1/2 hr from Margaret in zone 5B in Columbia County. Ive had great success with pink brandywine, mortgage lifter, oxheart, juliet and san marzano. I plant many others but those are my favorites. I too battle flea beatles and horrendous stink bugs and cucumber beatles but my tomatoes have escaped problems the last few years.
Normally we grow Purple Cherokee, Mortgage Lifter and San Marizono (which make the most heavenly tasting sauce). I’ll have to give some the other’s mentioned a try. I don’t bother with Rutgers any more, as those taste terrible when grown in our soil. sigh I have a Master Gardening friend that grows them and her’s are yummy. Puzzling, but I have a sneaking suspicion it has to do more with the differences in our well water than in the soil. Love all the suggestions and am taking notes, so I remember.
Hi, Catherine. Makes me want to investigate what affects tomato flavor from one garden to another…I guess I have some research ahead of me!
I always have Brandywine and Kellogg’s Breakfast. I am trying Amy’s Apricot this year, it is a non hybrid Sungold type. A tomatoe that I have lst seed for is Zapato pletted , it is yummy and looks like ruffled slices on your plate.
I grew indigo rose last year in Vermont . All hype, not worth the space. Interesting to look at but VERY late ripening. Looses black color when finally ripe though maintains a darkish tone. Flavor was meally and bland when all was said and done. Threw them in sauce pot and that was that. Won’t waste space on them again. Talked to local market grower about them and he had similar experience – said their best value was for interesting color in mixed boxes of similar sized tomatoes. He said he wouldn’t grow them again either.
Thanks for the feedback, Laurie. Love your solution: throw ’em in the sauce pot! That’s what I do here, too, with anyone that’s not the best. :)
I moved to the Hudson Valley in NY 7 Years ago from Staten Island NYC and have had problems with, amongst other things, flea beetles, squash bugs and blights of various forms. Three years ago I started Brandy Boy tomatoes from Burpee seeds along with Cherokee Purple and some others. I had grown Brandywine tomatoes a couple of times, but was always disappointed with the yield, and I was never bowled over with the flavor, either. Well. I have had great success with Brandy Boy and it is now my favorite with Cherokee purple right behind it for flavor and dependence. Brandy Boy is not an “heirloom”, I believe it is a hybrid of Brandywine and Burpee’s Best Boy but it is a great tomato for flavor, yield and the plants are healthy well into the summer. Highly recommended unfortunately, I think the seeds are only available through the catalog.
Cherokee Purple and Big Rainbow are two faves. If you are looking for profusion, Yellow Pear is hard to beat. Baxter’s Bush is a great red cherry. Tiny Tim is good in containers.
Wow…just all great perspectives and insights! Thanks everyone.
My favorite heirloom for disease resistance and general nice-ness is Vinson Watts. It’s a mid-size pink tomato that grows on a sturdy, blight-resistant plant. It’s a great slicer and ripens fairly early. It originated in Kentucky, where I live, so I may be biased… I also think Garden Peach is a cool tomato, really worth growing at least once even for it’s looks! It really is slightly fuzzy, and the color is a lovely peachy/yellow.
Hi, Katie. I have never heard of ‘Vinson Watts’! I did taste-test ‘Garden Peach’ last year at Seed Library, and the fuzzy skin was wild.
I’ve read good things about Indigo Rose and Rutgers but haven’t tried them.
I have trouble with a short season so I plant 4th of July, Early Girl. My most favorite is Sungold cherry!!! Yes they do crack if not picked regularly, but the flavor and early ripening make them wonderful for me.
I tried pink and red Brandywine but only got 1 huge pink before the season ended. I can’t remember the taste as it was so long ago and I decided not worthy to take up valuable space for 1 tomato.
I too loved the taste and amount of tomatos produced by Juliette but found if I did not get to the community plot to harvest daily, the ripe ones dropped off the plant.
My favorite for taste is Box Car Willie. It’s a med size red with a taste that reminds me of childhood. It was late to start producing but worth the wait.
I will look for Upstate Oxheart for a really big slicer.
Hi, Alice. I don’t know ‘Box Car Willie,’ but what a great name that is. And I think I will grow a plant or two of ‘Upstate Oxheart’ this year myself!
Tried Indigo Rose last year. Planted them too late so none ripened but they were very beautiful. I’ll try again this year.
Indigo Rose was a BIG disappointment as far as flavor was concerned. Yes, it’s unique. Friends took pics of my 4 ‘ plant loaded with fruit since this is the first true purple tomato of its kind. But, I will not be giving it any space in my garden this year. Last year’s favorite would be: Kosovo – Large, heart shape, sweet, meaty, few seeds and prolific. In zone 8 (Seattle, WA) I had fruit in mid August. My other favorite is: Fourth of July (mid-size, early, prolific, meaty and nice flavor).
Thanks, Carol, for the ‘Indigo Rose’ feedback. I have read about its good flavor but have not grown it, so this is helpful! I have seen photos of ‘Kosovo’ but never grown it. Good suggestions.
I agree Carol; ‘Indigo Rose was a disappointment here in CO too. Took forever to ripen, wasn’t very prolific and then in the end kind of meh in the taste department. Two years ago every stand at the farmers market carried them and last summer not a one had them.
I’m hoping that this year they’ll all be carrying ‘Padron peppers, one we’ve been growing since I brought seed back from Spain 7-8 years ago. It seems to be the food of the moment at tapas bars everywhere. They’re a delicious, mostly :) mild (I call them Russian roulette peppers) extremely prolific, super early and last to stop producing peppers. If you’ve never grown them, give them a try!
I usually get my seeds from TomatoFest.com or Bob’s and have tried a few of the varieties you mentioned. I love Carbon and Paul Roberson but also like Ildi, Green Zebra and Oxhearts.
Stay away from Red Currant tomatoes though. They are very prolific little pea-size cherry tomatoes (one year’s tomato size obsession) but they self-sew like CRAZY and come up EVERYWHERE, including my front yard and neighbor’s front flower beds!
My four new tomatoes for this year will be Indigo Rose, Giant Syrian, Purple Calabash, and Carbon. My mainstays are Cherokee Purple, Mortgage Lifter, Tigerella, and Mountain Magic. Based on Margaret’s recommendation, I think I’ll add Juliet to the mix.
Green Zebra, Cherokee Purple, Kellogg’s Breakfast, Matt’s Wild Cherry, Red Currant ( L. pimpinelifolium) , Wild Galapagos Tomato ( L. cheesmanii), Black Prince, Mortgage Lifter aka Radiator Charlie, Garden Peach, Wasipinicon Peach, Black Cherry, Aunt Lou’s Underground Railroad Red (Sadly, the original source doesn’t have it anymore, & mice ate what I saved. No volunteers either, despite some drops. Critters probably ate those too. I, & a couple others, would love to find it again.)
For sauce (really, any are good, just have to be cooked longer.) : San Marzano Lampadina Strain ( Pinetree Garden Seeds) The sauce has more of a “fresh” tomato flavor , than others I’ve tried. ( IMHO , ‘Roma” is the worst of the type.) It’s got better disease risistance than regular San Marzano.
Opalka is good too.
In the “So Far, So Good” file, ones that were good last year, despite the cool nights : Blush ( if you don’t like the cracking on the gold cherries, try this “elongated” cherry), Arkansas Traveler, Stone Ridge (HVSL), Abu Rawan (Baker Creek) , Golden Queen – USDA Strain, Azoychka, White Queen, Nyagous ( A woodchuck ate all but 1, and stripped that to a pencil-sized stick, but it still beat others to ripeness.), Nineveh (Baker Creek) a tart cooking tomato, that is round , not plum-shaped. ( I liked it raw, but others puckered.;) Ruth’s Perfect(Turtle Tree) did well. I couldn’t tell it apart from Mortgage Lifter. The first tomatoes were even ripe the same day. I wonder if it is the same thing. Maybe Ruth & Radiator Charlie got their original tomatoes from the same source?
I wasn’t impressed with the flavor of ‘Indigo Rose’. It was prolific, with a striking appearance, but the flavor was lacking. Maybe it will do better with a warmer season. From 7/15 until frost there was only one night in the 60s, with many in the forties. Hoping for better this year. ( Don’t we always? ;)
My favorites from last year’s garden are Marianna’s Peace (the best flavored red I’ve ever grown) and Chocolate Stripes (brown fruit with green stripes). Great White was also a surprise. I’ll definitely be making room for them again. This year I’m looking forward to trying Pink Berkeley Tie Dye and Gardener’s Delight Cherry tomato.
I’ve tried Indigo Rose and was disappointed with the taste — I think it’s more of an interesting conversation piece than anything.
Most of the heirlooms are wonderful and I echo the Sungold sentiment but one we like for BLTs is Persimmon. It’s an orange with a nice tang. Still think Roma is the best sauce tomato and you can’t beat Green Zebra for an unexpected taste. Will have to try ther blacks.
Black Krim were my favorite from my garden last year and I’ll be planting them again for sure. One favorite that we can’t get rid of is Matt’s Wild Cherry. They are rather small sweet cherries and I’ve not planted them for a few years but we always end up with quite a few from plants that I just let grow as they come up.
Hi, Eric. ‘Matt’s’ is a wild thing, indeed. Sort of like what happens w/my toamtillos…once you plant them, you have them! (I have to say for disease control I pull all self-sowns, which up my way can be “vectors” for overwintering tomato disease.)
Nothing fancy about this tomato; Red, tasty and juicy. But the best part is they’re ready for eating by July 4th !!!! All my neighbors become more friendly around the 1st in anticipation. Average size plant with a heavy yield thru the end of summer.
Oh, by the way, the name of the plant is……………..the ‘4TH OF JULY’ tomato
My all time favorite is Black Krim, but it might be time to try another black Russian type, maybe Paul Robeson. Love the SunGolds, but am getting pretty tired of the cracking problem they have. Time to try one of the up dates. Another favorite is an Ox Heart: seeds given to me by my CPA’s wife who got them from the son of an Italian immigrant who brought them with him sometime in the early 20s. They produce so much tomato and nearly no seeds. I have to be careful each year that I save enough for the next year. A crop failure would be a disaster!