there’s more than one way to ripen a tomato
AH, THE JUICY JOY OF A RIPE TOMATO—IF YOU CAN NURTURE ONE unscathed to that perfect shade of orangey-red, that is. In a hot, dry summer the chipmunks (who demonically begin taste-testing at about half-ripe) drive me to picking early and ripening every fruit indoors—which might not be such a bad thing, it turns out. It raises the topic of how to turn a tomato red (and perhaps the need for a recipe for green tomato “mincemeat,” too, just in case our magic fails).
what is ripening, anyhow?
RIPENING SOUNDS A LOT LIKE A MIDLIFE CRISIS in retired professor Brian Capon’s little masterpiece, “Botany for Gardeners.” His section on the topic, called “Hormones and the Aging Process” (!!!), outlines the biochemical events involved in what we hungry gardeners and cooks regard as a fruit reaching perfection. It’s actually the beginning of the end.
It’s all part of a bigger plan: Green chlorophyll breaks down and other pigments surface—which along with increasing softness and rising sugar content serve to attract animals (who will in turn serve to disperse the seeds inside). And the beat goes on.
The flavor change comes from the decline of tannins (whose pucker-up taste cleverly staved off those same beasts until the seed was ready). Chalk the softening up to ethylene gas (present in increasing amounts in aging fruit), which helps break down cell walls and membranes.
how to hasten ripening in the garden
IF YOU’RE WORRIED FROST MAY BEAT YOUR CROP to the finish line, a few tactics can induce hurry-up mode. One is called root-pruning, and couldn’t be simpler. Simply insert a spade just 6 inches or so into the soil in a circular pattern, circumnavigating the plant 1 foot away from its main stem.
Should cold nights threaten, be ready with fabric or plastic to keep frost off the vines. Even in cold zones, first frosts are often followed by another warm spell, and you’ll eke out more vine-ripe fruit.
what color is your tomato?
OK, SO MAYBE THEY’LL NEVER BE MARTHA STEWART paint-chip names, but tomato colors have official designations, thanks to the USDA Tomato Ripeness Color Chart (1975 edition, above).
Is your fruit simply a stubborn Green (self-explanatory) or is it Breakers (a break in the color from green is starting to be evident), or are you already at Turning (10 to 30 percent red showing) or Pink (30-60) or Light Red (60-90) or Red (more than 90 percent)?
when to give up and go indoors
I ALREADY SUGGESTED TWO INSTANCES: Do your ripening indoors whenever animals, or prolonged cold, threaten to get to the crop before you do. But intense heat can take its toll, too, says the Illinois Urban Extension, which recommends picking “pink” fruit when temperatures are over 90.
Alice Waters (in “Chez Panisse Vegetables”) isn’t alone in suggesting ripening indoors as a regular practice, picking when the shift from orange to red begins, reportedly to maximize sugar and acid content.
But what to do with the unripe tomatoes once inside? Here’s where it gets interesting—as in mixed advice. I confess to being a windowsill ripener, which apparently isn’t so bright (tee hee).
Most extension services recommend some kind of darkened space instead, achieved by tactics including:
- sorting the haul into categories: those showing some red, full-size green fruit (called “mature green”) and other green, and then…
- wrapping each fruit in newsprint to place in trays with others like it, or…
- placing similar-condition fruits in brown paper bags closed loosely, not stacking fruit upon fruit but in single layers, and…
- sometimes putting a bit of apple peel inside to up the ethylene, or…
- (if there’s no getting past oncoming weather) getting drastic by cutting down entire plants at the base and hanging them, fruits attached, in the cellar or garage…
- with all of this ideally happening in a cool, dry spot at 65-70 degrees.
Sorting by ripeness stage allows you to check on each batch, by opening just a few test wrappers. Mature green fruit should reach ripeness in about two weeks.
Everyone agrees: No refrigeration (unless you simply must keep fruits you plan to cook in a day or so from decaying). Rather than use the fridge, I prefer to freeze fruits whole in bags at peak ripeness, if I can’t use them now.
some will never ripen, no-how, nowhere, no way
THERE ARE ALWAYS HOLDOUTS, those who won’t cooperate even if given the TLC above. Immature green fruit, for instance, can’t turn red—no matter how your coddle it. How to tell which can and cannot?
Get out your knife. A tomato must be at least “mature green” to ripen off the vine, and if you’re not sure if yours are at that stage yet, sacrifice a representative fruit.
Slice it open, and look inside: If it’s gelatinous, it has a chance of ripening after harvest. You may also notice some color change on the interior, perhaps a yellowish tone—another optimistic sign that similar sized fruits will get there in time. If not: Skip to the green-tomato mincemeat recipe, below.
recipes for all shades of tomatoes
FIRST, A LITTLE TOMATO MEASURING TIP: In a recipe, 1 pound equals about 2 cups of chopped fruit (or roughly 3 medium tomatoes). With that knowledge, you could make:
- My quick tomato sauce (great for freezing)
- Tomato Junk (how I use up the last of everything in the garden)
- Green Tomato and Apple Mincemeat (great in pies, and also as a chutney–and meat-free)
- Herbed, roasted tomatoes to freeze
everything i know about tomatoes
THAT WOULD AMOUNT to this, from seed-sowing to favorite varieties to every manner of what ails them—and even how to graft one. Seriously.


Here’s another post from the Napa contingent with a literary twist. We had a wonderful tomato feast on Monday night, which inspired me to find a great quote from cookbook author Marcella Hazan:
https://literarylegacies.wordpress.com/the-literary-tomato/
Welcome, Julie, all the way from Napa. :) Sounds like that was some feast…life is good at harvest time, no? See you soon again, I hope.
It never occurred to me to ripen them off the vine (Doh!). They have been ripening sooo sloowwly. Here is a baked orzo, tomato and zucchini recipe from The NY Times. I have been eating it all week. Super easy and you gotta love orzo.
https://www.nytimes.com/2009/08/13/health/nutrition/13recipehealth.html
From the Napa gang, here’s a new tilt on tomatoes:
https://www.napanest.typepad.com/flourish/
Margaret,
Thanks for the welcome and I’m delighted to be the one to introduce pa amb tomaquet to you! It’s so simple, and miraculously delicous.
We had six courses of tomato & bread based dishes that night, so I’m guessing we put away about 4 pounds of tomatoes each. Then of course I ate some more the next day (as pa amb tomaquet of course) while writing my post… there’s no finer inspiration. Thanks for hosting this tomato celebration!
Living in Italy for the past two years, I really gained a new appreciation of perfectly ripe tomatoes. Here are a few of my favorite ways to eat them—straight from my blog, Flexitarian Foodie!
Avocado-Tomato-Peach salad
https://www.flexitarianfoodie.com/2010/07/savory-summer-fruit-salad.html
Basic Bruschetta
https://www.flexitarianfoodie.com/2010/06/bruschetta-say-it-right-eat-it-often.html
Tomato and Cream Cheese Foccacia
https://www.flexitarianfoodie.com/2010/04/focaccia-done-right.html
There are plenty more tomato recipes on Flexitarian Foodie, come take a look!
Here is my contribution to this week’s Summer Fest!
https://mysteriesinternal.blogspot.com/2010/08/red-for-journey.html
Love coming here and getting all the tips Summer Fest 2010 has been great fun!
You’ll find an Heirloom Tomato Salad with Asparagus and Herb Creme Fraiche at It’s The Way She…
https://itsthewayshe.blogspot.com/2010/08/cant-resist-heirloom-summer-fest-2010.html
Hi Margaret,
As always, your post is incredibly informative. I plan to go read your other tomato links, as well. I had a very decent year for heirloom tomatoes in my garden and I made a lot of recipes with them- today I posted about a delicious tomato ginger jam I made, and I also did a little recap of the other tomato recipes, in photos…
https://blog.healthy-green-lifestyle.com/tomato-ginger-jam.html
What a nice post!
This was my first time participating in the summer-fest n I enjoyed it so much. Here’s something Indian I did with my tomatoes.
https://www.indiansimmer.com/2010/08/tadka-tomato-dal-and-green-tomato.html
WOO HOO!!! This has been so much fun!!! I enjoyed reading your tips on ripening tomatoes … who knows, maybe one day I will find a hidden gardening gene!!! Everyone’s recipes sound wonderful and I can’t wait to go exploring! For this week, I am keeping it simple – Tomatoes with Feta Mousse
Already thinking about fallfood!!
For simple recipes like Roasted Tomato Soup, Brown Butter Tomato Vinaigrette, and an unusual and delicious Tomato Pudding check out my blog today https://thepolymathchronicles.blogspot.com/2010/08/summerfest-repost-tomato-time.html
That tomato junk sounds like just what I need as I’m cleaning out my summer garden and making way for fall. Thank you!
My contribution this week is two sauces for snacking and the pantry. First, a Charleston Creole Sauce that I’ve canned for winter eating:
https://heartlandrenaissance.com/2010/08/creole-sauce/
And second, a fire-roasted pico de gallo that I can’t keep stocked in the house! I make a batch at least once a week each summer . . . I make mine lacto-fermented just by adding a little whey and it lasts (fresh! uncooked salsa!) in the fridge for months. If it doesn’t get eaten first!
https://heartlandrenaissance.com/2008/06/fire-roasted-pico-de-gallo-2/
Thank you for hosting! I can’t wait to read all the other contributors!
Best,
Sarah
Wonderful and helpful tips for ripening. Thank you Margaret! And I love the book, Botany for Gardeners – wonderful resource for real-world application.
Thanks to all for the wonderful recipes here, I can’t wait to dig in. I have a spin on the traditional gazpacho recipe to share. I like to make mine with golden tomatoes, hence the name I gave it… “Golden Days of Summer Gazpacho”: https://www.thegardenerseden.com/?p=12865
Happy Harvesting!
Michaela
Great tips – thanks! I had such fun with Summer Fest this year
My contribution this week is roasted tomato soup with smoked paprika:
https://4seasonsoffood.blogspot.com/2010/08/roasted-tomato-soup-with-smoked-paprika.html
Glad to learn this information!!!
I’ve fallen in love with these Greek Tomato Fritters:
https://maitredemoda.wordpress.com/2010/08/25/greek-tomato-fritters-don’t-let-these-stay-greek-to-you/
Here I am, a farm girl, and I’d never heard of root pruning to speed a tomato along! (could be because I grew up in the feisty-hot California Central Valley) Anyway, I loved your post and am excited to take part in my first Summer Fest collaboration! Yes, why not start with the tomato?
I was with the Napa Valley bloggers above, napa farmhouse 1885 and Deirdre. Delightful! Here’s my take, plus a recipe for the surprisingly hearty Scalloped Tomatoes: https://bit.ly/c0RHfb
Great information, and I have loved working on Summer Fest 2010 recipes.
My contribution this week is:
Fresh Tomatoes with Basil Drizzle
https://www.ingredientsinc.net/2010/08/easy-appetizer-or-salad-tomatoes-with-basil-drizzle/
How interesting all the different tomato colours specifications are and what a wonderful idea Summer Fest is. Great post and good reading!
Margaret, thanks for including us all in Summer Fest. It has been quite the journey of self discovery and wonderful to meet so many new friends.
This is a great post on ripening our juicy summer tomatoes….it is fun to learn from you. Love that color chart!
Here is my contribution to this weeks Summer Fest:
Bacon Guacamole Salsa
https://su.pr/1kaInH
I love tomatoes, their a labor of love to grow, but they are the most rewarding. Here’s a little article and some favorite tomato recipes, my addition to summer fest.
https://www.gastronomersguide.com/2010/08/tomatoes-fruits-and-labors-of-my-love.html
we napa valley girls ate our body weight in tomatoes monday night in order to honor this most sacred week of summerfest. many thanks to gott’s roadside in st. helena for growing and dishing up such fabulosity! in my post, i raved about my favorite dish of the night, the classic catalan “pa amb tomaquet,” aka pan con tomate. https://hedonismink.blogspot.com/2010/08/gott-tomatoes.html
Welcome, Dierdre. How much did you eat? :) Your dish is a new one on me, so thank you for the education! See you soon.
ahh…tomato week…my favorite of the summer fest options. i posted two recipes…one for my slow roasted tomato sauce…and the “secret” gazpacho recipe from gott’s roadside restaurant in the napa valley…their tag line “tray gourmet” https://bit.ly/9Re3iY
Thanks for the tomato ripening tip! We’ve been picking tomatoes as they start to get ripe, and have been ripening them indoors. With all the bugs and other critters, it works for us.
This is a wonderful read…about one of our favourites…Tomatoes!! Thank you.
PS Also should let you know that the recipe for heirloom tomato tart with parmesan
crust is ‘no longer available’ at the Gluten-free Girl website. boo hoo. It sounds
delicious, though.
Hi Margaret,
Summer Fest 2010 has been a great foodie/online experience for me. For this week
I have decided to share my Cornwallville Fried Green Tomato recipe.
I have a plethora of them now and we are enjoying them fried up and dipped in our dill-basil mayo.
https://cornwallvillegardens.blogspot.com/2010/08/fried-green-tomatoes-for-summer-fest.html