OUR GARDENS AND FARMS—and lives—depend on pollinators such as bees, but these critical creatures are under grave pressure. Can gardeners help? Entomologist and pollinator-conservation specialist Kelly Gill says yes: by learning more about the life cycles of bees, particularly our native species, and acting more hospitably. Two copies of “Attracting Native Pollinators” from the Xerces Society are up for grabs in the latest giveaway.
Kelly is a Pollinator Conservation Specialist for the Xerces Society for Invertebrate Conservation, an international nonprofit organization that protects wildlife through the conservation of invertebrates and their habitat. In her dual role, she is also a partner biologist, based in New Jersey, with the USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service.
Kelly, who took her Masters in Entomology at Iowa State, provides technical support for planning, installing, and managing pollinator habitat across the Mid-Atlantic and Northeastern United States. She also conducts research aimed at the development of best practices for conserving beneficial insects in agricultural landscapes.
Our Q&A follows, from the latest edition of my weekly public-radio program (details on how to subscribe to the podcast are at the bottom of the page):
my q&a on pollinator conservation and gardening
Q. Before we get started, Kelly: Xerces.org–it’s one of those words I hear pronounced in two ways, as if the C in the middle is a K, and as if it’s an S. Which is right? And how did the society take that name—originally the name of an ancient Persian king, spelled Xerxes, I think?
A. We say it as if it’s an S, and it’s named after the Xerces blue butterfly. When the society began, we were focused on butterfly conservation, before our programs widened, and the Xerces blue is the first butterfly thought to go extinct due to human activity. [It lived in the San Francisco Bay Area].
Q. It may seem obvious that pollinators are important to our food supply and our environment, but what key plants do they interact with, and to what extent?
A. About 35 percent of our crop production worldwide can be traced back to some kind of insect pollinator. And that pollinator is usually a bee. That’s worth billions of dollars to U.S. crops annually. About $18 billion to $27 billion worth of crops here depend on pollinators—hundreds of billions of dollars worldwide.
One in every three mouthfuls of food we eat and drink can be traced back to a pollinator, including most of most vitamin-rich and nutritious foods.
Q. Some examples of insect-pollinated crops?
A. Some of our favorite fruits are insect-pollinated (including apples [blossoms above in Margaret’s garden], peaches, strawberries, raspberries, blueberries, cranberries) and some of our favorite vegetables, such as the cucurbits (squash and melons and pumpkin).
And then you also think about it beyond the obvious—of crops like alfalfa, that are grown for seed to feed our livestock. To get that seed, those plants need to be pollinated.
Q. In the East and elsewhere, many or maybe even most of our wildflowers, for instance, also rely on insect pollinators to reproduce and thrive.
A. You hit on one of the big ecosystem services that pollinators not only provide to humans, but to wildlife as well. Pollinator-produced fruit and seeds provide about one-quarter of mammal and bird diets. The creatures we love to watch in our gardens–they’re likely benefiting from a pollinator as well.
Q. So who are the key pollinators?
A. A pollinator is loosely defined as a flower-visiting insect, and a lot of insects visit flowers for different reasons. But bees really depend on pollen and nectar as adults—the form you see flying around visiting flowers—and also as a developing, grub-like larva.
The other insects may take pollen and nectar from flowers as adults, but during their other life stages they don’t always depend on it like a bee does.
So these bees are purposely collecting pollen as they move from plant to plant, and they really co-evolved with these plants—in their body structures and their biology—to be the ones transferring the majority of this pollen.
[More about key pollinator species from Xerces.org.]
Q. Which makes me think of how fuzzy many bees’ bodies are—good for gathering pollen.
A. They’re like little dust mops—they really are made to get the pollen all over them. And they have structures on their legs where they can accumulate and transfer the pollen, and transport it without it falling off.
Q. Do butterflies, flies, or wasps pollinate?
A. There are certain plants that are butterfly- or moth- or fly-pollinated, and some of those are very specialized plants. But sometimes just incidentally as they gather pollen for themselves, they will transfer pollen from one plant to another with their bodies—but they don’t collect it purposely to feed their young, and they don’t have these co-evolved structures on their bodies.
Q. Can you take us through a basic mini-course on pollinator biology, and the types of bees?
A. A lot of times when we picture bees, we picture a hive of honeybees—a big box overflowing with worker bees, and a big colony. That’s actually atypical of bee biology, and of the bees that are native here.
The honeybee was introduced about 1620, and for awhile was managed for honey production. With the growth of agriculture, it became one of our most important crop pollinators.
But there are also 4,000 species of native bees in North America, and they vary greatly in appearance. Some are green and shiny and metallic, more like a fly, and some may be more recognizable, like the bumblebees (which are native).
Most of these native bees live a solitary life, and don’t have a colony, or a queen—except for the bumblebees. The bumblebees are social, but have a little bit different kind of colony than the non-native honeybees.
Honeybee colonies are perennial—meaning the queen can live several years, and the colony overwinters, and persists that long.
With a bumblebee colony, it’s more annual. A mated queen starts a new nest. Right now, the mated queens are hibernating under leaf litter or underground, and they’ll come out and start a new colony in spring by themselves.
Most bees don’t have thousands of worker bees helping them like the honeybees.
Q. What is causing the decline in pollinators? Which are under most pressure and why?
A. We haven’t found one specific reason. Many things are affecting the health of honeybees, ranging from diseases and pathogens, parasites to honey prices—many people think the stress of moving the colonies around [in commercial agriculture, from farm to farm as crops bloom] is part of it.
All of these factors are compounded by the fact that all pollinators are experiencing a poor diet from habitat loss. As we develop land, and expand farming—larger areas that once provided habitat are being lost, with a reduced diversity of diet resulting.
Q. What about chemical pressure?
A. We know a lot more about the effects of pesticides on honeybees than about our native bees, though research on them is growing by leaps and bounds. As far as we can tell, it can affect any type of bees.
If you have a honeybee nest that’s compromised by a pest such as a mite, and also experiencing habitat loss, then you pile exposure to something poisonous on top of that–it just gets harder and harder for a bee to fight this off.
Not just insecticides, but also herbicides have an impact—the “weeds” they kill might not be a crop, but might be providing pollen and nectar nearby when a crop’s not blooming.
[More on chemicals and their effects on pollinators from the Xerces Society.]
Q. How can individuals contribute, then, with whatever patch of ground they manage—park, backyard, town square?
A. Everyone can do something in their own yard or community to help bees, by taking the pledge to bring back pollinators. It includes four steps:
1. Plant a diversity of flowers in your yard that produce abundant nectar and pollen. [Region-specific lists of pollinator plants can be accessed from this page on the Xerces website, or by using their interactive map, from which you can dig deeper and get pdf’s of plant recommendations for your area. Emphasizing natives is recommended.]
2. Protect nest sites. These can be in the ground, or in pithy, hollow plant stems, or in woody material. Protect nests that you see, and try to plant some of these hollow-stemmed plants (such as elderberry, or brambles, or even some native bunchgrasses like little bluestem, which they like to nest under). If you have a corner of your yard where you can have a brushpile or leave thatch on the ground—an area where you don’t clean up as carefully—you can put your pollinator habitat sign there. Less disturbance means more habitat for pollinators. [Links to more on bee nests and how to build them from Xerces.org.]
3. Avoid using pesticides. [More on pesticide effects, from Xerces.]
4. Spread the word to others in your community, and make it a joint effort. [The Xerces Society has various citizen-science programs under way; start at their pollinator conservation homepage. or the Bring Back the Pollinators program.]
prefer the podcast?
KELLY GILL and I talked pollinator conservation on the latest radio podcast. You can listen anywhere, anytime: Locally, in my Hudson Valley (NY)-Berkshires (MA)-Litchfield Hills (CT) region, “A Way to Garden” airs on Robin Hood Radio’s three stations on Monday at 8:30 AM Eastern, with a rerun at 8:30 Saturdays. It is available free on iTunes, the Stitcher app, or streaming from RobinHoodRadio.com or via its RSS feed. The March 10, 2014 show can be streamed here now. Robin Hood is the smallest NPR station in the nation; our garden show marks the start of its fifth year in March, and is syndicated via PRX.
how to win the pollinator guide
I’LL PURCHASE TWO COPIES of “Attracting Native Pollinators: Protecting North America’s Bees and Butterflies” (Amazon affiliate link), the Xerces Society guide, for the latest giveaway. All you have to do to enter is answer this question in the comments box below.
Is there an area of your garden that’s particularly abuzz in spring and summer? What’s the source of the pollinator excitement?
Me? I’ve stopped mowing a swath above the house that includes native little bluestem grass and other goodies, and I also include many pollen- and nectar-rich plants in my gardens—both natives and non-natives. I include extra flowering things even in my vegetable garden (calendula, zinnia, sunflowers, etc.), where I also let a small amount of each crop (lettuce, arugula, chervil, dill, carrots, broccoli…) flower and go to seed as attractions.
Feeling shy, or have no specific answer? Just say, “Count me in” or some such, and I will.
Two winners will be chosen randomly after entries close at midnight Sunday, March 16. Good luck to all.
(Photos from my garden of insect pollinators, top of page to bottom, on Corylopsis, garlic chives, squash, apple blossoms [shown without insects], Clematis, zinnia, and Angelica gigas.)
more on being wildlife-friendly
- Monarch butterflies: Their plight, and how to help
- Hummingbird mints, salvias and more
- I know what birds like (making a bird-friendly garden)
- How I’m mowing differently to add more diversity
- The water garden: Where the action is
- Or just hover your cursor over the word NATURE up top, and see the categories–from frogs or birds to mushrooms or insects–drop down to choose among.
Lambs ear left to flower really attracts the bees. Rosemary is another one that they love. Pretty much all of the herbs. They also love the native Toyon flowers and Ceonothus flowers
Count me in.
Pollinators are especially attracted to my Salvia “Indigo Spires”!
100 x 100 ft corner of my 1 1/2 acres is left to the pollinators!
The bees love my dandelions because they are one of the first flowers out. However, even the dandelions don’t arrive quick enough so i put a bit of raw honey on a jar lid, in the sun, with a tall pink vase near to attract the bees to feed until the flowers are aplenty. When the bees no longer come to my feeder i know they are busy pollinating. :-)
I love to watch early pollinators at my clumps of coltsfoot.
Last year for my spouse, I ordered a mason bee house filled with dozens of little tubes, and several years-worth of refill tubes. This week, we ordered the mason bee cocoons appropriate to our region. Because they live here already and we see them around the yard, we’re hoping that the new bees that hatch and the existing bees will mix genes and take up residence in the bee house. I lve mason bees and their color variations! I’d love to have honey bees, but I don’t feel quite up to the task of bee keeping. Yet. :)
For me its either Verbena bonariensis, Comfrey or Borage- these are my 3 top plants for pollinators as they flower all summer long and the bees absolutely love them.
Speaking of attracting animals to the garden, is it worthwhile trying to attract bats to help control the mosquitoes? We have a bat house, but no bats. I looked to see if you’ve done any posts on bats and don’t see any. Might be an interesting topic.
We got a bat house for the holidays last year. And though I am excited about it, I understand that getting/hoping/encouraging a bat to move in is tough. They are particular creatures about a lot of aspects of their environments. All you can do is locate it in an ideal location and hope for the best. Good luck.
ENTRIES are now closed but your comments are always welcome.
And the winners are: Corinne, and Katherine (who have been notified by email).
Thank you all for this amazing conversation.
I am a bee keeper (4th year) and have had mixed luck: 1st batch died after the 1st winter, 2nd batch produced 45 pounds of honey in the 2nd year. This year, I hope to continue the success and have ordered 2 more hives and packages of bees. My understanding of honey bees is that they are largely attracted to flowering trees (catalpas, horse chestnut, cherry) because there are hundreds of thousands of flowers to choose from. A vegetable garden, or zinnia patch, though helpful, are not what is keeping the honey bee alive and thriving.
I am convinced that it is pesticides that are killing the bees because experienced beekeepers are treating for tracheal mites and the Nosema virus, but they are still losing their hives. Unfortunately, there is no way to stop ones bees from visiting the chemical laden gardens of our neighbors. And although Bayer makes chemicals that do not kill a bee outright, the toxins, like lead in water pipes, build up in the hive until it becomes a toxic environment.
Pollinators that are not domesticated honey bees? I don’t know too much. Count me in.
On a side note: Margaret, I assume from reading your blog that you are not a bee keeper. You could probably host a hive, or 5, on your property by way of the local beekeeping society. I think that you would find them as fascinating as you do your frogs.
Count me in.
I have planted a whole are of our yard in wild flowers and love it as there are so many different varities along with herbs, and garden beds with different plants.
Unfortunately in suburbia where I live too many neighbors have come to rely on chemical lawn care. Due to that I have lost a major selection of plants from the chemical drift & the disappearance of over 90% of the pollinators & birds too…
From the devastation, you would never know my gardens were a few years ago on the local garden tour…611 people came through to see. Sadly I need to start over!!
I hate to mow… most of my yard are gardens with flowers opening at different times.