‘saving the season’ apple butter recipe, with kevin west

Kevin West's apple butter, from "Saving the Season"

SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA-based but Southeast-bred Kevin West strikes me at once as a very modern and also a very old-fashioned guy–a great combination to my mind. Quotes from the classical Roman poet Virgil open the chapters in his book, “Saving the Season: A Cook’s Guide to Home Canning, Pickling and Preserving,” which is also loaded with old-fashioned fruits he hopes we haven’t forgotten about.

But the recipes are smart, and the science and food safety is up-to-the-minute 21st century.  Kevin joined me on the radio when the book came out, to share his best seasonal tips, and his apple-butter recipe (photo above).

When we caught up, Kevin was between batches of quince paste and fermented West Indian gherkin pickles–and about to head out for a leg of his book tour. The book is loaded with tips and tricks for anyone wanting to put up fruits, from apples to pears to the more unusual types, including the how-to’s of quince paste (a.k.a. membrillo); crabapples (as jelly or poached); damson plum preserves, and other antique-fruit recipes, right through to green-tomato tricks.

Kevin’s apple butter recipe is excerpted below.

Kevin West, author of "Saving the Season"


kevin west’s apple butter

(yields 2 pints)

Reprinted with permission from “Saving the Season,” by Kevin West; and in his words:

"Caving the Season" by Kevin WestSWEETENED WITH APPLE CIDER—no added sugar!—and very lightly spiced, this apple butter is mahogany-brown and intensely flavored. I use a mixed bag of apples, a third of which are acidic varieties such as ‘Granny Smith,’ to get the proper sweet-tart balance. Unlike the other fruit butters in this book, this one does not have the apples puréed at any point in the cooking.

The texture is better if you begin with sliced, unpeeled apples, and then allow the long cooking and frequent stirring to break them down naturally. Also unlike many apple butter recipes, this one has the spices added in tiny quantities toward the end of cooking. As I say elsewhere, you can always add more spice if you like, but you can’t take any out.

During cooking, the ingredients will reduce to about one-third of their initial volume. Stick a bamboo skewer straight down into the pot at the start of cooking to gauge the depth of the ingredients. Mark the level with a pencil, and keep the skewer handy as a guide. Given the hours-long cooking time, a slow cooker, its cover lifted by two chopsticks laid across the pot, would be convenient for this recipe.

  • 5 pounds mixed apple varieties, including 1⁄3 tart
  • ½ gallon unfiltered apple cider
  • 2 allspice berries
  • 20 fresh gratings of cinnamon
  • 10 fresh gratings of nutmeg

Quarter and core the apples, then cut them into 5⁄8-inch slices. (Leave the peels on.) Put the slices in a deep ovenproof pot, and cover them with the apple cider. Bring the pot to a boil, reduce the heat, and simmer, uncovered, for about 4 hours, stirring every 15 minutes.

At the end of that time, most of the liquid will have evaporated, and the apples will look like chunky applesauce. Grind the allspice in a mortar and add it to the pot. Use a Microplane grater to rasp off the suggested amounts of cinnamon and nutmeg. Transfer the pot to a 300-degree oven to finish reducing. Stir every 10 minutes. The butter is done when it’s stiff, mahogany brown, and reduced to about one-third of its initial volume, after about 90 minutes in the oven. In the cold- saucer test, a teaspoon chilled in the freezer for 1 minute shouldn’t leak liquid at the edges. Taste and adjust the flavor with more spice if you like.

Pack the hot apple butter into four prepared wide- mouth ½-pint jars, leaving ¼ inch headspace. Run a skewer or other thin implement around the inside edge to release any air pockets. Seal the jars, and process in a boiling- water bath for 10 minutes.

Note: Sealed jars will keep for a year, but because there is no added sugar, apple butter will mold fairly quickly once opened. Refrigerate open jars, and plan to use them within 10 days.

(Excerpted from SAVING THE SEASON by Kevin West. Copyright © 2013 by Kevin West. Excerpted by permission of Knopf, a division of Random House, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.)


how to enter to win ‘saving the season’

I’VE BOUGHT two extra copies “Saving the Season: A Cook’s Guide to Home Canning, Pickling and Preserving,” by Kevin West, to share with you. All you have to do to enter is answer this question in the comments box below (UPDATE: The giveway is finished, but comments are always welcome):

What’s the most unusual, or old-style, fruit you’ve cooked up this season–and did it find its way into your pantry, freezer or just onto your table?

I’m still applesauce-mad over here–nothing unusual about that–though my fruit comes from the trees in my garden that are over 100 years old, so perhaps it qualifies!

Have no anecdote to share, or feeling shy? That’s fine–just say, “Count me in” or some such in the comments, and I will. Two winners will be chosen at random after entries close at midnight on Monday, October 7. Good luck to all.

(Disclosure: Amazon affiliate book links yield a small commission that I use to purchase books for future giveaways.)

  1. barbara says:

    I ordered a box of apples and pears from a local organic farm and for the first time made apple/pear sauce. Just added a shake or two of cinnamin and it is delicious. Would love to win the book and expand my perserving.

  2. Carolyn says:

    no fruits as of yet , but a few batches of tomatillo salsa and a ton of batches of tomato sauce and veggie juice. ( tomatoes are fruit so i guess that counts)

  3. Julie says:

    Please count me in! I didn’t ever seem to find time to put up anything this year (so far). But I read tons about recipes and foods I wanted to make….

  4. Karen Champion says:

    Thimbleberry jam! Boom! Our cottage is on Whidbey Island north of Seattle. The best place we found to collect our little gems was our dog park. We made a rule to pick only berries waist high and up to avoid those who may have been “watered”. Careful washing too!

  5. Jean W says:

    Not unusual but I’m making pear/apple butter at this very moment. Trying it with no sweetener, so we shall see. The pears were so sweet. Stirring often on low heat, and will can it if it comes out yummy.

  6. marla says:

    Making apple butter in the crock pot as we “speak”…dehydrator is humming with apple rings and apple leather…but the pies de resistance is the pasticcio of cucuzza, tomatoes mozzarella and lots of basil, parsley, thyme, egg and breadcrumbs. Makes a great no noodle type of lasagna. I also made some stevia in vodka.

  7. paulette says:

    100 + year old pear tree. I made a rustic coffee cake with spiced pears on top and then i used my freeze drier to preserve many of the rest.

  8. Eleanor Cone says:

    Apple butter is a favorite I put it up in half pints because it does mold pretty quickly after it is open. It is great on pancakes.

  9. margie says:

    Count me in. Made applesauce three different ways. Dried apple rings, canned cinnamon apples, apple pie filling. No exotic fruits available here though.

  10. Peg Denton says:

    I only canned applesauce this year, but I’m itching to go find some more apples for apple butter now. I can always use someone’s wisdom shared in a book, so please count me in!

  11. Rita Hlasney says:

    I candied jalapeños..love the sweet and heat. Great to swirl through cheesecake before cooking or on crackers with cream cheese. Or on grilled meats.

  12. Kari says:

    Nothing unusual in my garden, although I am planning on putting in a Jostaberry next year. Too much applesauce from last season still crowding the frig, so I am using your crockpot method to reduce it. Should give me extra room in the freezer, plus something I could add to yogurt too. I wonder if you could use it to make a glaze for an apple or spice cake?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.