intimate relationships: a tale of moss, sumac, and a clever aphid’s gall
AH, THE RELATIONSHIPS! Alongside the mossiest patch of my lawn, a vigorous cutleaf staghorn sumac grows. I use that plant in several other spots in the garden—both the plain green Rhus typhina ‘Laciniata,’ and also the gold-leaf cultivar called ‘Tiger Eyes.’
But this particular sumac, the one beside the mossy lawn, always gets colorful, pod-like galls in high summer, as if it were festooned with tiny bright balloons, mostly greenish but some red and appropriately heart-shaped (above). My other sumac plants, not so much.
And I never knew why.
I knew it was an aphid—specifically the native sumac gall aphid, Melaphis rhois—who created the gall, typically found on staghorn sumac or smooth sumac (Rhus glabra). My friend Charley Eiseman had told me that on a walk several falls ago. It doesn’t do any damage, though some leaflets may color up or fall off a little early. The insect is just making a nursery on its host plant to rear its offspring, a relationship that’s been going on like this for at least 48 million years.
What I didn’t know Until Joe Boggs of Ohio State wrote about it was the critical moss connection—a case of what’s called an alternate host (not just sumac, in summer, but moss in the offseason). His blog post got me reading all manner of geeky sumac gall literature.
Apparently females lay an egg on the underside of a sumac leaf, which causes a gall to start forming—creating a nursery, complete with food, for its offspring. That single aphid resulting from the deposited egg then reproduces asexually within the gall—by parthenogenesis—so that many clones of itself eventually also fill the gall.

Well, except at my place sometimes things get interrupted when someone (chipmunks? birds?–not sure as I haven’t caught anyone in the act) breaks open the galls and systematically has at the contents, the way I might eat a piece of citrus fruit and discard the skin. Lots of empty gnawed-open galls on the ground beneath that one sumac at the moment here, along with ones that seem to be faring better, presumably filled with teenage aphids by now.

If you are friends with Charles Eisman, then perhaps he had already shared with you the miracle of Canada Goldenrod Gall. As a naturalist in Maine I have been awe-struck for decades when I teach learners of all ages the life cycle of this fly and the larvae within over the winter. If you are curious about the details let me know and I’ll share the story.
We just found an acorn plum gall wasp! We got so curious about this round lumpy brown/orange ball we found as we were on a walk. Did a little research and were so surprised with what we found! It grows on an acorn from a red oak tree.
Such fun to find!
Quite an interesting read! I wonder who is gobbling some of the galls up. I read more about parthenogenesis.
Just discovered a related aphid situation but I wish the chipmunks or someone would crack open the galls and feast. My story is that I’ve planted a woodland understory wild little side garden in MA not too far from Boston. I have transplanted from a family home in the Berkshires: Hobblebush viburnum, striped maple, native witch hazel, and moved from my own yard spice bush and encouraged maple leaf viburnum. Lovely. But over the past few years I’ve noticed my Actea bugbane suffering from lots of dead leaves, stems, generally not looking their usual splendid selves. And incidentally I’ve kept a keen eye out for their volunteer babies and popped the tiny Actea throughout this woodsy side garden. Meanwhile I have noticed many, many cone shaped galls all over the leaves of the nearby set of witch hazel. I thought oh fine, it’s part of the wildlife gardening I do, the aphids growing similarly to yours are part of the picture. But in the past few days, now armed w a homemade Dr Bronners soap spray, I realize what is negatively affected my Actea is… too many aphids, the cottony fuzzy ones that are as quick as fleas when I try to pinch them. Not sure what to do. Cut back the witch hazel loaded w the aphid galls? Keep soap spraying my Actea? And yet the aphid lifecycle as indicated in this article, though a different kind than mine, is complex and not a single thing to manage. Any thoughts welcome! Rghhh.
So many interesting tidbits of natural history info out there, as many as grains of sand on a beach.
Galls are so cool, thanks for sharing. I like to imagine how great it would be if humans could ask trees to simply make us a home and we would protect/defend them for the magnificent beings they are, rather than us seeing them only as things…a resource to exploit.
So interesting! Parthenogenesis is so… cool. Do the winged females mate before dropping/flying to the moss, or is the whole cycle asexual? If entirely asexual, that’s a heck of a lot of clones! Trippy!
Fascinating – love the rabbit hole research you share!
I have 2 acres of highbush blueberries. Over the years I have studied the Blueberry Stem Gall wasp. It was identified in N. Ontario Canada on low bush blueberries. Here in WNY we have two life cycles based on my research {organic patch} over the years. Galls spark a lot of curiosity it seems.
Gallformers.org is a great resource for gall identification. Type in the host plant genus or species, specify the location on the plant (leaf, stem etc.) and you can scroll through photos to learn the name and natural history of the gall-forming organism. It will open up a whole new world of fascination in any garden or natural area!
Thanks for the tip about Gallformers.org !
Yes, thanks for the tip about Gallformers.org!
We are just beginning to pay attention to galls in our neighborhood here in central Connecticut
You might like this very old post and want to seek out the field guide featured in it.
I just watched a chipmunk feeding on our sumac galls. My curiosity to learn more about the little guys obsession the last couple days has led me to your website. I have a great video to share with you. Caught in the act, if you will.
THANK YOU for this wonderful article! I JUST discovered these galls on my smooth sumac, the first time I’ve ever seen them in my 70 yrs, and was struggling to find any info on them. :-) They’re green now, and look very figgy, but I look forward to following the progress, now that I know what they are. :-)
Is it a particular type of moss that these aphids live on?
I don’t know if it’s specific to a species of moss, no.
Thank you for your post. The galls on my Staghorn Sumac look exactly like the photograph – red and green. It’s only the second season for my sumac and I just noticed them yesterday.
It happens every year here — part of nature’s many little wonders! Fascinating.
Thank you for this. Only one of the wild sumac that grows along my driveway has these. I have puzzled for years on what they were. Great to know finally!
We have simular galls on Manzanita here in Northern CA. Just looked it up.
Never knew that they were nurseries! So much fun to read about.
Thnak you. Always something new to learn from you :}
I am having such fun learning more, more, more — so thanks for the encouragement, Shana.
I had noticed these on you last Garden walk, thinking “fruit on sumac!?” So thank you for the detail and explanation. Always a pleasure!
Wow, that’s so neat. And such a pretty looking gall- but that pretty color obviously attracts the nibblers to come and snack upon them!
What do we know about the witch hazel gall?
Nothing … but now you have me reading, starting at NC State website and following links at the end and down another rabbit hole!
At least it is a pretty gall, in that I like the color.
I have moss. I have sumac. I will be on the lookout for this aphid.