growing annual poppies, with marilyn barlow

s249ogI DON’T RECALL where the annual poppies that have been replanting themselves here and there around my garden for decades came from in the first place, but I’m glad they made themselves at home.

I’m always happy to see any poppy, anywhere, in all their flouncy forms like old-fashioned party dresses, in a range of colors from delightfully, shockingly bright orange and reds to the palest Victorian-style pastels, and even white.

I was thinking of growing more poppies, so I called Marilyn Barlow of Select Seeds, who has tried her hand at more than anyone else I know.

I realized that Marilyn and I were sort of having our silver anniversary of knowing each other–since when we recorded this interview it was 25 years since she first toured me through her Connecticut garden of oldtime flowers, most of them unfamiliar to me—old, maybe, historically speaking, but brand new to my eyes. Then (it was in 1991) the “nursery” that is now Select Seeds was Marilyn’s yard, and the “office” was her kitchen table.

Select Seeds is all grown up now, and the current catalog has loads of poppies in it along with other goodies. She joined me on my public-radio show and podcast to talk about all manner of annual poppies, and to learn to grow poppies from seed.

Read along as you listen to the February 1, 2016 edition of my public-radio show and podcast using the player below. You can subscribe to all future editions on Apple Podcasts (iTunes) or Spotify or Stitcher (and browse my archive of podcasts here).

my annual poppy q&a with marilyn barlow




Q. I mentioned that the Select Seeds business is all grown up, Marilyn, and I should have said so is your daughter, Allison, who works in the business with you.  

A. A long time ago—I think it was 1995—“Country Living” magazine featured her on the cover. I think she was 5 years old at the time, and in the garden, of course. So now she’s at the desk, on the computer.

Q. And I think we have her to thank for managing the project that brought you a wonderful new website in 2016.

A. Work in progress; we’re going to add a lot to it, but it’s a big difference.

Cosmos b. GeelQ. Before we get to poppies: I was going though the physical 2016 catalog, and there are so many cheerful, bright things in there, including a new Cosmos that’s a softer yellow and shorter stature. Tell me about it.

A. That’s from a Dutch breeder, Rob Van der Voort. He’s been doing a lot of very interesting things. With Cosmos, he bred a few new ones because it’s the year of the Cosmos, in Europe especially, so he got some new varieties going.

Do you remember ‘Yellow Garden’? It was super-tall and really late—and it started blooming in September or October here.

Q. So the picture looked beautiful if you happened to get a snapshot, but as a garden plant it was a little too late and too lanky.

A. Yes; very lanky, which I don’t usually mind too much, but it was very late. This new one is more compact and a lot earlier. A lot of gardens are smaller, and more compact seems to be the way some people are going to fit in more plants in their smaller spaces. So it’s shorter…

Q. …like it’s 2 or 2½ feet?

A. It still has a nice fullness to it, and the color is really beautiful with the cream-white and the soft yellow.

Q. I forgot its name; I didn’t jot it down.

A. ‘Xanthos.’

Q. Right, for the yellow color.

A. I think he got the Fleuroselect Gold Medal for that one; it’s a real new introduction in the field of Cosmos.

Q. Now poppies: Do you recall what your first poppy was–whether in your garden or the catalog, Marilyn?

A. I have to say it was the ‘Heirloom’ poppy [top photo, and below]. I was sent a collection of seeds by a gardener—and that’s how I get a lot of my seeds, really, or I did. People would trade with me, and say, “You might be interested in this.” So I got some seeds and started growing them and we made it an annual thing.

s249og-1It’s a mix of a lot of different fringed and tulip shapes. The ‘Imperial Pink’ poppy was a selection from that.

Q. So what genus and species are we in now, because when we say poppy, we mean a ground of related genera in the poppy family, or also a number of species and groups within the Poppy genus.

A. We have 30 different poppies, but that includes California poppies, and the opium type poppies—somniferums—and the somniferums that we designate as the fringed type and peony type poppy, laciniatum and paeoniflorum, respectively.

And then of course the corn and Shirley poppies.

Q. This ‘Heirloom’ one that you then selected one variety out of…

A. That is a somniferum [Papaver somniferum].

poppy buds in various stages DSC00107Q. It always gets everyone agitated because they are the opium poppy (or breadseed poppy). I think they’re wonderful, and especially love the pods. Even if they didn’t have a beautiful flower, I love the dried pod. It’s so preposterous that nature created that pod. [Laughter.]

A. They have two sepals, and when they first raise their heads—the whole bud points downward at first [above], and then it lifts upward, and the two sepals fall off and release that beautiful flower.

Q. So it releases the flower and we get the bloom and…

A. With the stamens on the inside—there are so many of them, and the bees just cluster around them as soon as the flower opens and even sometimes just before to harvest all that pollen.

The center turns into that capsule, into that fused stigma. They talk about the crown on top of that poppy capsule, because it looks like a little crown. It’s really decorative.

12310621_1077497405607205_1899701655060496285_nQ. And then as it gets ready to develop seeds inside, and then dry, it sort of opens those little windows, just below that cap, and it’s like a shaker. The seeds would disperse themselves from those little holes. It really is an incredible contraption. [Laughter.]

A. And when the seeds are ripe inside they do shake; you can hear them rattle around if you tap the plant.

Q. So the opium or breadseed poppy is one, and I don’t know if they’re technically sub-species or strains—but the ones that are big puffballs and crazy-looking, fluffier things. Like you have ‘Black Swan,’ which I think is in the laciniatum group.

A. Generally we call the very doubled, very fringed ones laciniatum. The paeoniflorums are the ones that you can see in those 16th century and 17th century still lifes. They’re that big classic blowsy flower that is featured in that type of artwork.

Q. You sell them as seeds, and in some cases you sell plants. I’ve always done best when the plants have sown themselves. So let’s talk about sowing annual poppies in general, and then we can double back and talk about some of the other species like the corn poppy, Shirley poppy… With some of the poppies on your website, it says there are like 1,000 seeds in a packet, which means, “Oh my goodness, they’re really small!” [Laughter.]

A. Generally speaking, and if you’re direct-sowing you kind of need [enough seed in the packet] that will give you something to work with. You might not need 1,000 plants—none of us do. But you’ve got to have something to work with that has some weight, and you don’t all of a sudden sneeze and then, “Where’d they go?” [Laughter.]

Q. When you say “something to work with,” do you mean to add something to the seed, like sand?

A. We don’t.

Q. I’ve seen pictures in books and so forth where people add sand to the seed and then shake them around out of a sifter, but I’ve never done that.

A. I haven’t because we generally sow a larger quantity. It just helps so you don’t dump them all in one pile, just to spread the seed out so it doesn’t get too crowded, because they don’t transplant that well.

If you get them too crowded, you’re going to be thinning out too many of the little seedlings.

Q. And having to discard them, once they’re uprooted.

So with the breadseed or opium poppy—the somniferums—you have done this for many years. When do you like to get them started? I know probably some of the older ones in your garden and elsewhere are doing it themselves. What’s your timing and method?

A. We sow them in a garden bed that is specifically just for flowers—it’s not tucked in among other plants, the way it seems like other people might do it. We cover-crop our garden beds, so in that case they’re not really ready to go until the ground has dried enough to turn under the cover crop and rake the beds, which could be the beginning of April or the beginning of May. But generally we try to start them in April.

If you have an area that’s bare, you could sow some as soon as you can kind of scratch the ground with a rake.

Q. You mean like all winter this winter in the Northeast? [Laughter.]

A. It has been a little unusual. But if you already have the bare ground, and you can scratch it, you could put the seeds down and then firm them in, so they have good contact with the soil. That could be March or April, around our area.

Q. So firmed in doesn’t mean poking them down like you would plant an edible pea or a squash seed—it doesn’t mean burying it in a hole. It just means pressing it into the soil surface?

A. Like with the back of a hoe, tapping it so that if we get some rain it won’t wash them away, because they’re in firm contact with the soil.

Q. So if we have the open ground and we can scratch the soil, we’re probably doing this in April (and you and I are in the Northeast)—or as soon as the soil can be worked. And then we keep our eye on that area?

A. It’s pretty easy to tell because a lot of these poppies have a bluish-green leaf, so it’s evident as soon as they germinate and come above-ground and have true leaves. They’re easy to differentiate from a weed.

Q. They don’t transplant well, so we’re leaving them in place, mostly. Now can we also sow them inside, if we have ultimate patience and a steady hand? Again, you sell some as mail-order plants, so how do you do that?

A. Surprisingly we’ll even start them on heat; we haven’t found that they absolutely need cold to germinate.  They’ll come up pretty quick even on heat. And we do transplant them, once from a tiny plug cell into its final pot [for shipping to customers]. And then we grow them on, much cooler.

We have luck with that as long as you don’t try to tear them apart if there should be two plants in the pot [when you receive it from us], when you transplant them—as long as you transplant that whole rootball that we sent, they should catch on pretty well. That’s what we do even for the seed crops here, or if I don’t have enough growing and I want to make sure my spacing is right, I might just plant out pots.

Q. When you start them indoors, would it still be in that early April time, or even earlier? I’m interested because I might want to try some both ways. As you point out, the garden is not all open soil—I might want to start some indoors to transplant into spots.

A. I’m thinking about six weeks indoors.

Q. You put them on a heat mat, they pop up fast, and then you grow them cool. [Above, the opium poppy selection ‘Danish Flag.‘]

A. They do come up pretty fast under heat, but I don’t think it’s necessary. Room temperature is fine. And then you will transplant them out [in April in the Northeast]—you don’t want to keep them too long in that pot because they really can’t have any checks to their growth.

Q. If the root finds impediment, you don’t want to disturb it?

A. You don’t want it to end up trying to flower. If you keep it too long in the pot a lot of these things may want to start to flower even though they’re only 6 inches tall or so. You want to keep the light really bright, the fertilizer half-strength on a regular basis, and the temperature cool once they’ve come up, and before you transplant them, so they’re really ready to go once they’re planted in the ground.

Q. If I do it inside, do I try to put a couple of tiny seeds into each cell?

A. [Laughter.] You try.

Q. It’s so hard, Marilyn.

A. Your success is related to your level of patience. I generally tend to oversow even though I try not to. We would put about three seeds into a cell, and then we would ;pick the strongest one.

Q. Would you snip off the other two?

A. Yes, or tweezers—just as soon as they come up you can tell which one is the one that’s getting up and moving along and growing well.

Poppy American Legion s927Q. Some of the other annual poppies besides Papaver somniferum—like the species rhoeas. We have the corn poppy and Shirley poppy in there. What’s different about those? They have some bright colors, is one thing.

A. They have those bright reds, and the corn poppy called ‘American Legion’ is scarlet red with white blotches in the center to create a cross [above]. I do like that bright color in spring—it looks good with larkspurs, that contrast of a dark blue and the red poppies.

Q. It’s beautiful.

A. I think growing them in very similar. The leaves aren’t that blue-green; they’re more of a green color.

Q. So if we do direct sow them we would be a little more observant, because they could get confused with weeds. Not that I ever have any weeds in my garden…[laughter]. You don’t have any weeds, do you?

A. No, zero tolerance.

Q. Well, I have no tolerance but it doesn’t mean that the weeds understand my point of view. Actually right about now I’d be happy to go out weeding; in midwinter it sounds like fun to be able to go out and do anything.

In that species of Papaver rhoeas, we also have the Shirley poppies—which are not always bright-colored ones, is that right?

A. Yes, they include the softer pastels, where you get into some of those lavenders and almost gray and pale pink, and combinations of those colors.

399 poppy dawnQ. A friend of mine used to call those colors—which also appear in antique iris—the colors of Victorian ladies’ lingerie. Some are almost grayish. [Above, a mix of P. rhoeas.]

A. They used to call that color heliotrope back then.

Q. Are those similar height and bloom time?

A. I usually think early summer, so June into maybe July around here. And they’re about 2 feet tall. The opium poppies, depending on your soil—which should be fertile and very well-drained—can be around 3 feet or so. These are a little bit shorter.

One of my favorites is the ‘Ladybird’ poppy.

s374Q. That’s a commutatum—once again, a different species. Is that the one that the Royal Horticulural Society gave a prize?

A. Yes, I think it won an Award of Garden Merit from the RHS. It’s nice because some of the really heavy-headed ones like our carnation poppy [below] and sometimes the peony poppies—just like a regular peony they might need a little support if grown in a rich soil, especially during some rain. If they’re not supported or underpinned, they might fall over. But the smaller ones, and the ‘Ladybird’ poppy in particular: It’s short, compact, and stands up really well, and has those gorgeous, brilliant flowers with a dark blotch. The habit is really nice, and I think it fits into a lot of different types of gardens.

s1305Q. What about the California poppies, which are a shorter stature still. When do you start them? [Below, Eschscholzia californica ‘Appleblossom Chiffon,’ a California poppy.]

A. Those you start again in early spring, and you need pretty well-drained soil. Almost the best way to have those poppies is to allow them to self-sow, because they’ll find the perfect place in the garden that suits them just fine, and they’ll come up from year to year.

Q. So try them in a few places and see where they are happy, and then let it do its own thing?

A. Yes, they especially like well-drained, and we have a rich, organic soil so they’ll sort of go to the edges, near a gravel path. They’ll find just the right spot.

Q. It’s funny how they know just where they want to be. As I said at the beginning, my breadseed poppies know where they want to be and they don’t want me to tell them. [Laughter.]

And you have one perennial poppy that you sell seeds for—the Oriental poppy [below, ‘Princess Louise’]?

A. Yes, and I really like them, but I don’t have enough to hardly mention them. But I like them because they disappear later, and I love annuals. So I can plunk an annual I’ve started in a pot right in that empty spot, or right near it, and have a continued show through the summer, because hr Oriental poppy sort of bowed out in July.

Q. So poppy-on-poppy, that’s your layering tactic, Marilyn? [Laughter.]

A. Sounds good.

more with marilyn barlow

prefer the podcast version of the show?

MY WEEKLY public-radio show, rated a “top-5 garden podcast” by “The Guardian” newspaper in the UK, began its 11th year in March 2020. In 2016, the show won three silver medals for excellence from the Garden Writers Association. It’s produced at Robin Hood Radio, the smallest NPR station in the nation. Listen locally in the Hudson Valley (NY)-Berkshires (MA)-Litchfield Hills (CT) Mondays at 8:30 AM Eastern, rerun at 8:30 Saturdays. Or play the February 1, 2016 show using the player near the top of this transcript. You can subscribe to all future editions on iTunes/Apple Podcasts or Spotify or Stitcher (and browse my archive of podcasts here).

(Photos courtesy of Select Seeds. Disclosure: Select Seeds is an occasional seasonal advertiser on A Way to Garden, and a longtime friend.)

  1. Michael Z says:

    Thanks, Margaret. I’m growing poppies for the first time this year, and I went online to learn a little more today. Low and behold you had exactly what I needed when I needed it. I couldn’t ask for more!

  2. frederique jennette says:

    so glad you discussed these as they are not only my favorite but especially this year I had already done some research as to which ones I would like to plant so this really helps!
    thank you!

  3. Nancy Schaefer says:

    I just went through my Select Seeds catalog yesterday and marked what I want to order for this year – now I’ll have to go back and look at the poppies again- too beautiful to not grow more of them!

  4. kathy says:

    Thanks for this great episode. A friend gave me some poppy seeds from her garden where they reappear each year. I have already scattered most of them about, keeping some in reserve, just in case . . . I hope they find somewhere in my little yard to their liking.

  5. Mark says:

    Good friends who volunteer at the Enfield Shaker Museum gave me some poppy seeds last year from the gardens there. I presume they’re an opium/breadseed type. I know nothing about how to grow them so this has been a timely podcast. I’m looking forward to seeing them bloom in my garden this year!

  6. Sharon says:

    I have tried so many times to grow poppies here in Roanoke VA (zone 7b). I’ve tried seeding in the fall, in the spring, putting in plants. Zip, nada. Should I give up? Is it too warm here?

      1. Julie says:

        I wish Margaret had answered this as I too have not been successful with poppies. This year I will try again. I’m in zone 6, Lancaster County PA.

        1. margaret says:

          Sorry, Julie. I know many people who grow them in your area, and even warmer. The hardest part (as you have found) is getting them started — they are better at sowing themselves than we are at sowing them sometimes — and hopefully some of Marilyn’s suggestions in this interview help, whether you want to try in late winter in the open ground or in cells to then transplant, or better yet both.

  7. Patty says:

    I am going to try poppies again this year! I’d like to know what that plant is behind the “Ladybird” poppy is? A monkshood?

  8. Beverly, zone 6, eastern PA says:

    I have enjoyed breadseed poppies for many years in the haphazard colonies they develop on their own. Many mutations appear, differing numbers of petals, varying shades, ragged edges or smooth edges… it’s a very entertaining plant.

    I grew the famous ‘Lauren’s Grape’ poppy in a separate area to try to preserve its deep color. I saw the developer, Colorado gardener Lauren Springer, on a TV show a long time ago as she described how she culled all the wrong colors for several years to get to this stable dark purple poppy from seed. So interesting.

  9. What beautiful images of the poppies. I had no idea there were than many varieties. I once had some flanders poppies that somehow took over a large portion of some bare land after I’d planted them in a nearby garden area. I loved looking at that red field. Unfortunately, they did not return the next year.

  10. Dahlink says:

    I have tried several types of poppies over the years and have had no luck. They might come up the first year, then they fade away. I’m tempted to try again, though, seeing these luscious photos.

  11. Cheryl Siracusa says:

    I’m wholly inspired to try these! I’d always thought they ALL preferred infertile, sandy soil. So glad to hear I can in fact grow some varieties in my heavily composted beds. Thanks!

    1. margaret says:

      You’re welcome, Cheryl. My longtime opium poppies here grow fine in good soil, and shorter in stature in the cracks in my walkway/patio.

  12. Renee says:

    I have seed for both the breadseed and shirley poppies. I’m thinking of planting some in containers for my patio and I don’t have a garden space. Will this work and how big of a pot should I get?

    1. margaret says:

      Yes, you can do so. Make sure the pots have good drainage holes and that you used a well-drained medium (not garden soil) in them. I think bigger is better as for pot size (think tubs, not small flowerpots), and I also think they make nice accents jutting up above lower-growing annuals in a mix container.

  13. Martha in Texas says:

    Marilyn Barlow & Margaret Wise Woman, Thank you!

    You prompt a lovely memory of walking among a small field of poppies, deep red, black centers, about 2-3 ft. tall–and so was I. The visual scarlet is a perfect picture-postcard memory, but it is the lovely waves of scent that are most poignant. My Papa was an enthusiastic gardener, by hobby, maintaining a vibrant a diverse 1/2 acre vegetable garden, for us and to share with friends and family. Also a great teacher, he would grow an acre of something, just for me, and to share with my school–wheat one year, involving us in planting and field trips from school to watch it grew, make heads. He’d found a remaining mill, involved me and my grade school class with all of it, the harvesting by scythe, binding, going to mill, everyone taking home a bag of flour. More idyllic than I had an awareness of at the time–it was just what Papa did.

    Every years, he’d do something different: corn, sugar cane, clover, gladiolus (yes an acre of glads!) and poppies. No, he didn’t make a product out of the poppies, but the seeding and blooming and seed pods rattling were a strong memory to keep, and were my school science project that year–my classmates totally enjoyed the rattling pods. And for me, at home, walking in those lovely scented poppies, and later the breeze going thru that acre of seed pods, those smooth pods, and the whisper-y waves of tiny rattling.
    For a moment i am there again, among lovely, lovely poppies..
    So. BIG thanks for prompting a special memory.
    Martha in Texas

  14. ks says:

    Here in Northern California often Poppies are sown in late fall or winter. I think tou would find this typical on the west coast. The winter rains ( if we have them ) will aid in the germination process. It is better if they bloom early;they dislike the dry summer .

  15. Becky says:

    Loved all this information about poppies. The first time I was introduced to poppies was a sweet surprised. We were remodeling a old farm house. There were lots of old wood siding stacked along the fence. Don’t know how long it had been there but we moved it and that spring bread seed poppies grew and bloomed.

  16. Joanne Murphy says:

    I’ve just discovered your podcasts, and have been zooming through them. So happy that I’ve found you! I know this poppy interview is from awhile back. I do have questions for you and your guest. At the public garden I work at, I tend to the flower garden and depend on self-sown poppies each year. Our beds are color themed. My question to Marilyn is about whether and how she keeps her poppy crops separated to insure that the resulting seed will produce a known color and type. Thanks!

  17. Carol wichman says:

    Thank you for this article. I’ve had volunteer poppies in my garden for years. Mine look like roses and a rather large.


    I haven’t had much luck with poppies here in Ballston Spa. I have one Oriental (perennial) one hanging on. My soil tends to alkaline (hydrangas bloom shocking pink, when they bloom at all!). Could this be the reason poppies don’t flourish here? I have tried plants and seeds.

  19. Rita Hlasney says:

    A friend , since deceased gave me the salmon peachy carnation type poppy seeds 20 years ago. They do chose where they like to grow and mine seem to like gravel where I live in SW Missouri. Another friend gave me lavender carnation type poppy seeds a few years ago, so now we have lots of both colors. My husband calls them “his poppies” and tries to sow where he chooses but they come where they may. I have a pound of seed each fall to share with garden club ladies but only a few have have succeeded with a some germinating. Thinking we might try some different types after reading your conversation. Thanks for the inspiration.

  20. alison corning clarke says:

    i have had absolutely no luck with California poppies either here outside Boston or on coastal Maine. They mostly germinate and then disappear…i have tried different locations and different amounts of water. i also have a bad rabbit problem…could that be the problem and if so, any suggestions? i do see them around town in cracks and crevices so i know that they can grow here.

  21. Maryfran Hrynik says:

    I am an opium poppy lover and usually scatter them on top of a late snowfall in February or March, which works great. They bloom in June here in zone 5 in MI.

    But what I need help with is the small red poppy that blooms all over Europe. Currently I have seeds reaped in Greece and Giverney. Any advice for success with them?

    Love your site!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.