garden tip: first, make things worse
I‘M BUSY MAKING BAD SITUATIONS WORSE THESE DAYS, which is exactly what has to be done to bring any garden from now to a visually pleasing high summer and fall. It’s not unlike cleaning your closet: Things have to get pulled apart and look a lot messier before they get better. Really. The butchery around here extends beyond the huge swaths of beheaded bigroot geranium (Geranium macrorrhizum), above. Want the hit list? Feeling brave?
Some euphorbias, particularly the basic early spring yellow species called polychroma, will start to flop open and get mildewy here if they don’t get a brutal cutback, so you can see (left) what I’ve done to them (same thing I do again in earliest spring before new growth begins).
The new red-foliage polychroma cultivar, ‘Bonfire,’ seems to stand up better to summer, so I’m not chopping it down. Will I regret it? Don’t know…only my second year with the plant, so it’s all an experiment.
Which is what cutbacks are: You observe what is going on, and if it’s not looking good, you consider administering a haircut.
The pulmonarias were shorn to the ground after flowering last month, and already have a new set of showy leaves (instead of tattered, about-to-mildew old ones). They would have grown a new set right up and over the old, but I prefer to just shear them, rather than fussily deadheading each flower stem.
Perennial salvias, like the popular ‘May Night’ and the nemorosa varieties ‘Snow Hill’ and ‘Caradonna,’ can do with a good, hard cutback when they’re done blooming. A new rosettes of foliage will be emerging down below, and a lower-impact second flush of bloom will eventually be mustered.
Catmints (Nepeta) look a mess when they pass their first major bloom, so hack them back I do (again, same treatment as in earliest spring), forcing another flush of foliage and perhaps more flowers. Again, most of all what I am seeking to do is avoid having to stare at big, ugly, floppy plants long past their prime. I’d rather have a tidy, smaller mound of fresh green and a bit of a hole than a gone-by mess.
Apparently some visitors here agree, including two from mores southerly zones (John and Writermom, see their comments), who confessed to cutting down their spring-flowering Clematis recently after intense heat had fried them. Again, experiments. One, so far, reported success, even though the books won’t tell you summer Clematis butchery is on the recommended list.
With anything you are this harsh on, be sure to keep an eye on watering while it rejuvenates. And don’t panic, or at least not right away. Some plants (like my euphorbias) will sit there looking like you killed them for a week (or two or three). And then, most times, they’ll get up and growing all over again.
Given any good haircuts lately? Perhaps that stringy hanging basket of petunias?

Hi Margaret! I very happily marched out after reading the haircuts section of the July Garden Chores list, and cut back my hardy geranium (sorry, name unknown) that was looking just pitiful. Even shorn it’s better than it was and already there is new growth on it.
hi margaret,
what about dicentra spectabilis? It still has quite a bit of foliage, but it is yellow. Can i cut it back? I have also read they like quite a bit of room, but I would love to put something that blooms late summer in their spot.
ps. i’m with you. cutting out leggy/ratty/dead foliage is one of my favorite gardening tasks
@Laura: Definitely take down the Dicentra. It won’t regrow probably till next year, or not much. I think you can put something annual in the hole, yes.
Welcome, Maggie (a name I like to be called, and am by my best friend and a few other longtime pals). I love that we energized and emboldened you to go at the Geranium…at your service!
Welcome, Anna…and no, you don’t have to do anything. It’s your garden, and the way it looks and how you run it is all your deal. It’s “A Way to Garden,” not “THE Way…” or “The ONLY Way…” Really.
Welcome, Zina, to A Way to Garden. Paralyzed is the right word, and after all these years I still get stuck there, too. Susan, who has helped me in the garden fr years, will say “We should cut down the Xxxx today,” and I say “Can’t we wait a little longer?” and get all chicken. It’s our annual dialog, and actually kind of funny now. Like the dental appointment you want to postpone if you think it’s going to hurt, you know?
@Anna: Sounds like you’ve overcome the fear because of good results. Thanks for sharing.
I enjoy cutting things back (and I also can get really into cleaning out a closet), but I get confused about the nepeta I have in a border. I hate how floppy they get, but I also don’t like the idea of a border getting shorn.
I get a bit paralyzed! Any suggestions?
Like Ted, I pull out the bloom stalks from Geranium Brookside, G. Magnificum, and G. Nimbus, and am left with a nice little mound of new foliage. G. Samobor needs more drastic measures: cut it to the ground and it will regrow in about 3 weeks. In the meantime, I use a container plant to cover up the bare spot.
Can I cut to the ground Primula ‘Wanda’? What about Brunnera “Hadspen Cream”?
Boy, I really feel like the outsider here. I dead head and cut back some, but never cut back so hard anymore. I just don’t think the ugliness is worth it. For things like bigroot geranium, lungwort and lady’s mantle I just give the spent bloom stalk a firm tug and they pull from the base, leaving the foliage behind. I trim salvias and nepetas back to healthy buds, but never down to the ground. I guess I’m just willing to put up with a little more imperfection, and inflict on the gardens I tend.
So true – my catmint get a good cutting back after the first flush of blooms and if I keep after my pansies they will bloom until frost. I’ve also found that my purple flowering lamium goes from drop dead gorgeous in spring, to leggy and not so attactive in July. I give it a drastic cutting back (by then there’s already new growth near the ground) and it perks right up.
Oh my! Just what I’ve been up to as well. The other big chore was cutting off all the over-the-hill flowers on the big blue hostas. Since I really just like the foliage I think that next year I’ll consider not even letting them bloom at all – seems like that would be easier. I used all the various trimmings to make a nice layer of organic stuff in a new lasagna bed I’m starting, so progress on that front!
AWWW, do I have to? I hate to cut down plants. I know it’s trimming them up for brighter days–but it’s so brutal. Good advice and your weblog is just awesome. I got to go look at your gardens.
@Pru: Yes, hosta blooms…i could live without most of them, except late, fragrant large trumpets of white H. plantaginea, which is great.
@Ted: Sounds to me like you have done your own experimenting and found formulas that work for you just fine. So many factors at work; I just have miles of some of this stuff, and it’s unbearable looking in such masses when it all flops open from mid-July onward, or goes mildewy all at once. I used to do the pulling thing w/the flower stems, but once the beds got so big (and I planted so many new areas, oops!, with such big swaths) I found big scissors or grass shears just worked faster. But I get what you’re saying…the bigroot geranium rebounds pretty fast, but some of the others can be ugly for a good long spell.
Welcome, Pam. Yes, my bazillion ‘Samobor’ get the hatchet after bloom, too. I haven’t ever grown Wanda primulas, and the various kinds I grow usually get swamped by other things all summer (like nearby hostas that leaf out) and so I haven’t noticed them enough to cut them back. I have cut back Brunnera when some leaves got brown-edged and crispy looking in dry times, but not regularly as a matter of course. But if something looks ratty, I would probably at least cut out the bad leaves (or more).
margaret,
thanks so much for the post today. my nepeta are looking so overgrown and bad, but i haven’t had the courage to cut them back until now. so thank you. same goes for spring euphorbia which are looking bad. i gave one a major haircut last week, but haven’t had the guts to take care of the others. as for my pulmonaria, they’ve responded well to cutting back so far. this is my first year with mrs. moon…totally dreamy. puts her neighbor roy davison to shame. plus my dicentra spectabilis are ready for big cleanup. ah spring ephemera. thanks again. i love your site.
I always feel the need to apologize to the roses after I prune them. The look so sad for a few weeks, but it is always worth it.
Okay.. I’m convinced that you’re psychic Margaret… before I even came in to AWTG this evening, I wrote on my weekend to do list: ‘Cut back tired plants.’ (which by the way was written on the back of an envelope) Nature is rather amazing.. one week things are lush, green and full then with a bit of heat and a day or two without rain, it looks like the end of the season for some. So, I’ll be spending my Saturday doing the three C’s: Clip, Chop, Compost.
While we’re at it, put me down for a cut and color… a bit too much of the grey is showing…
Time to be cutting back the tomatoes here in Austin…past time, probably. I’m looking forward to that lovely fall garden.
Welcome, Deb, and welcome, Elizabeth.
@Deb: Roses are especially tough, you are right. After bloom the climbers and ramblers really need it, or they just get too crazy. I wonder which others you prune where you are; perhaps some floribundas need deadheading? (And p.s., love the wild “monkeys” on your blog.)
@Elizabeth: Go for it with the Nepeta…they will look dead for a little while, but be brave. The pulmonaria really do benefit, and the bleeding heart…well, I just cut like 15 of them, really big clumps, to the ground. I don’t expect much back where they stood, at least not till next spring, but it’s a relief to be rid of their sorry spent selves for now. Annuals, anyone? Or even just a fresh layer of mulch where they were would be better than what they looked like.
@Kenn: I thought we agreed not to talk about fast-growing gray hair. :)
Got my haircut yesterday as well!
You mentioned leggy petunias. I have some in both the front and back yard and they are getting really tall and leggy. they are still blooming profusely though. Should I cut them back some, if so how far?
Hey, lets all go together!
Welcome, June! Thanks for the hyssop link, and the quick trip to Asheville, NC (haven’t been there since a native plant conference eons ago, but beautiful country). This is a hard lesson, and frankly I posted it partly to make myself go out and do it, too…a little scary to be brutal, but it’s key.
Welcome, Melissa. “Blooming profusely” doesn’t sound like “leggy” to me. Hmmmm…hard to tell without seeing. If they look stringy and the blooms are not all the way consistently up and down the stems, I would give them a haircut. A way to experiment if you are afraid: Trim back some stems hard, some halfway, some not at all. See what happens. Or maybe do one or two stems hard, one or two not at all, and most halfway. Again, an experiment! Also, petunias are hungry guys, so douse them regularly with a fish-emulsion and seaweed extract diluted to recommended strength (look on the product label).
Oh its so nice to see you write about this! I have recently been feeling conflicted about cutting back my plants. Want to get rid of the tired looking overgrowth but was not excited about having a bunch of sticks poke out of the ground. The horehound I cut back looks excellent now. I also seem to cut back my hyssop at just the write time:
https://tinyurl.com/5gw29z
I cut it before it got overgrown and it filled back in nicely without having to go to the stump of sticks phase.
Thanks for the info, I have some cutting back to do!
It’s so funny because just like Brian I also made an appointment to get my longish hair trimmed. I think we’ll all feel cooler from a cut!!!
The annual Salvia that I started from seed my very own self (please, no applause) is very leggy. It is just blooming now but looks weedy. If I cut it back at this point will it bush out or am I too late?
You also remind me I’m looking pretty shaggy myself. Must make appointment for a good pruning.
This is excellent advice, Margaret. The recently shaved plants in my garden remind of the 1950s summer crew cuts my brothers used to sport!It has also given me narrow windows of planting space to tuck in a few showy annuals so that when the “hair” starts growing in, there will be skirts at the bottom of their feet. So far polygonum, pulmonarias, geraniums and some early spring grasses have seen the sharp edge of my secateurs. Never thought about doing the same to euphorbias as that white sap always makes me think they’re being bled to death. But I’m out the door now to sharpen the knives and give it a try- I’ll let you know the results.
First, just this: I love you guys.
OK, got that out of my system (but really, it is SO helpful this first fulltime season of my life in the garden…after decades of just a couple of days…to have you all to “talk” to.
@Brian: I got a haircut yesterday. Phew! I think it’s one of life’s best pick-me-uppers, after cleaning a messy closet (but easier).
@Terri: Eek! I am afraid now that you are going to behead your spurges…what if they hate you for it? But if they do get mildewy and nasty in high summer, like mine, I guess it’s the best course. Onward!
@Cindy: Welcome to A Way to Garden. This is one of the very hardest lessons in gardening (after the one about giving up on certain plants that just won’t “do” for you once you’ve tried several times).
Cutting back is so hard to stomach sometimes, and I was ashamed to show you all the post (the photos especially) as if I’d done something WRONG. If the garden doesn’t look perfect, I am embarrassed. Funny, huh? Do we need to exhume Sigmund Freud to figure out who’s got some control and self-esteem issues over here? Might be me… :)
Oh, I am terrible at cutting back! I always feel so bad for the plant. Silly, I know but I do feel mean as I perform the necessary task. In fact I have a catmint in some serious need of a makeover. Add that to the ever growing list of garden to do’s.