‘horticultural how-to and woo-woo’
the source for organic gardening inspiration margaret roach, head gardener
Search the Forums
A Message from Margaret Roach
The Urgent Garden Question Forum is part of A Way to Garden, but there is a difference between it and the blog itself. Stated simply:
On the blog, I choose the topic and post about it, and readers may wish to comment in response.
On the forum, the subject matter is driven by you. You initiate the conversation, and (hopefully) chime in to help one another and just get acquainted. I will stop in, but not answer every question; this is a place for community-driven discussion about anything reasonable that interests gardeners.
To post on the forum, you must register. The process is simple (link above). To get a photo to accompany your posts, called a Gravatar, go here.
Four overall things will enhance the experience:
Search before asking a question to see if there’s already a thread (and even maybe an answer!) on that subject.
Scan the list of forums within the system to see which one is the place for your post.
If you want to have general conversation, the General forum would be the best place to begin.
When you do post something, give it a good subject line (title) – so not “A Perennial Question” but “How to Divide Daylilies” or “When to Transplant Peonies.” This makes the topic more accessible to others who may have your answer.
For important etiquette rules, please read “Getting Started” at the top of the Forums. Thanks for your visit.
privacy shrubs screen– part sun — deer resistant – does it exist?
The super challenging problem is I have a 70 foot long area adjacent to country road and my house in Catskill which I would like to plant privacy shrubs screen the deer will not like. Currently there are a row of old lilacs. The nearby forsythia (which deer do not touch) create a privacy screen through their dense overgrown branches even in the winter. However a 70 ft long forsythia hedge screen is scary. But if I could mix with other fast growing shrubs it might be ok. Thinking spirea, rose of sharon. It’s a country natural woodlands kind of place. Ideas for other shrubs to intersperse?
Some quick part shade suggestions: Cornus sericea, Aesculus parviflora (bottlebrush buckeye), Rhus typhina (staghorn sumac), Pieris japonica- not sure if the native species (pieris floribunda) is also deer resistant, but I suspect it is.
Not sure how much sun and moisture you have, but I just planted a 80′ hedge of willow along a rural road at my studio (also in Catskill!) Deer are a real problem here, although we also have the problem of wet ground.
I have a mostly privet hedge between my yard & my neighbor’s driveway. There are incursions of barberry, forsythia, burning bush, and some little boxwoods – but I’d like to keep replacing the privet with other stuff. The problem is that they can’t spread much – they need to be more columnar. Anything in Leslie’s list that fills that bill? Or other suggestions? It’s somewhere between partly sunny and partly shady.
Try looking at a small cultivar of Viburnum trilobum (not deer resistant) such as compactum; you may still need to do some pruning to keep it in its place, but I have seen this working well in NYC to screen between two properties. Also Pieris japonica is neat and generally taller than wide, however it is slow growing.
Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
‘never stop wanting more plants, my garden mentor instilled in me 20-plus years ago, regularly reminding me of another gardener, past 90, who still lusts for every new thing he can get a cutting of. I promise not to, until I myself am back in the soil.’